RazorStar 4,025 Posted December 13, 2011 This may be a bit of creep going on, but I figured this would be as good a time as any to bring this up. For the past two years I've been running these tournaments so the members of TGP could determine the best player in the NFL in a method everyone would agree with. Last year Troy Polamalu narrowly edged out Aaron Rodgers for that title, but things might turn out differently this time around. I've also introduced a new method of going about this process from last year, before there was a preliminary round, a seeding/elimination round, and then a straight tournament of 128 players. Here are the logistics for this new tournament: Prelim Rounds, Each team gets 5 representatives, along with a pool of wildcards. This pool of wildcards will be reduced to 32 overall, 4 per division. Prelim Voting: Voters choose 6 best players on each team, and rank them from best to 6th best. The 5 players with the most votes move on, the rest of the players with votes move to the wild card. If there are ties for the 5th spot, those players are dropped to the wildcard round, and more wildcards will be added to that division. Example Vote: (Chiefs) +6 Branden Albert +5 Eric Berry +4 Derrick Johnson +3 Tamba Hali +2 Brandon Flowers +1 Brandon Carr Example: (Final voting for the Chiefs) 1. Eric Berry +35 2. Derrick Johnson +32 3. Tamba Hali +20 4. Jamaal Charles +15 5t. Branden Albert +8 5t. Brandon Flowers +8 --- 6. Brandon Carr +6 ...Other Chiefs... All of the chiefs players with less votes than Charles will have been dropped down into the wild card pool, and only those top 4 players will be for sure in the next round. Wildcard round: The wildcards in each team of a division are put into a big pool. From there, the top 4 players in each group are decided by voters taking their 4 best in each group and ranking them from best to 4th. Ties for 4th in these groups go into a final pool if necessary between all divisions. Example: (Wild Card AFC West Final Voting) 1. Tim Tebow +32 2. Louis Vasquez + 23 3. Brandon Carr +15 4t. Stanford Routt +6 4t. Robert Ayers +6 --- 6. Antoine Cason +4 7. Willis McGahee +3 Tebow, Vasquez and Carr would become AFC West Wildcards, while Routt, Ayers and Cason would move to the final wildcard round in order to fill the spots left by the 5th Chief (Prelim condition) and the 4th AFC West wild card. They could also fill in at other divisions if need be, but surviving wildcards will fill in at their own division if possible. Final Wildcard: Any stragglers left to fill in the holes in divisions are brought here. They'd be the players with the highest votes in each wild card that didn't make it, or the players tied for 4th in wildcards. There may be more wild card losing players added as necessary due to the conditions of the preliminary round. This group will undergo a sudden death hurt heal round, where players are eliminated until the wildcards fill necessary holes. Example: (Hurt Heal Final Wildcards) Jordy Nelson 1 Stanford Routt 1 Robert Ayers 1 Michael Vick 1 Jairus Byrd 1 Antoine Bethea 1 etc etc 1 Voters would give +1 to the player they thought was best in this group, and -1 to the player they thought was worst. This continues until there are only as many final wildcards left as there are spots to fill. This step may not even be necessary at all depending on how voting goes. Once the 192 players are decided, 24 per division, each division is broken into groups of 4, where the top vote getters in the preliminary rounds for each team lead a division. From there, players are arranged via snake order (using vote totals in prelim rounds) until each sub division has 6 players in it, making 32 divisions in all. Each division will be named after the team the top vote getter is from. (I.E the division with Eric Berry in it would be called the Chiefs division.) Round Robin: Each division has players go in head to head voting matches for 24 hours. After each player faces every other player in the division once, the players with the two best records will move on the final tournament. Ties will be allowed for this round, much like soccer and the world cup. If there are ties for second place after the matches are done, a simple 24 hour head to head tiebreaker will play out. If there are 3 or more players are tied for second in a division, it's simply a 3 or more way tiebreaker voting match. Once the 64 finalists are decided, the tournament becomes straight head to head voting. I may make it double elimination, but it's more likely to be a single elim with voting for 3rd, 5th and 7th place matches. Seeding will be sorted as fairly and evenly spaced as I can muster. The tournament goes on until only the best player in the NFL is left standing. This process will do quite a few things right. One of the problems we had last year is that good teams were given near equal clout against bad teams, and that the seeding/elimination round didn't do much for seeding, leaving it to prelim results, which were scewed by some teams getting more votes than others. Another issue was the fact that strong players in the division often eliminated each other before making the final rounds. Here, more players from good teams will get in, while only the best players on bad teams can get in easily. This should ensure that we're looking at the best field possible, and the most accurate results. The round robin method hasn't been tested yet, but I believe it will give us a better representation of who the top players are when we get to the field of 64. I'll work on a way for the super 64 tournament bracket to be fairly distributed, and this thing will start a week or two after the Super Bowl, since it'll need a bit of extra time to run through this off-season. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted December 13, 2011 This may seem like a lot of words, but the process should explain itself as we go on through. This is also the best place to have any questions you have about this tournament answered. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted December 26, 2011 Ok, we're gonna start the preliminary rounds now. These should go on for a while, so let's get a lot of discussion and a lot of votes for the teams in each division. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
seanbrock 1,684 Posted December 27, 2011 My top 5 prediction Rodgers Brees Brady Ware Revis Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SteVo+ 3,702 Posted December 27, 2011 Good to see you're getting this thing going again, Razor. Always makes for fun discussion. Though isn't it a bit early this year? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted December 28, 2011 It is. However the Prelim round is gonna go on for a while yet, I was thinking about a month or so for it. The structure needs quite a bit more time too, since there are more rounds to go through. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted January 20, 2012 (edited) The Preliminary round is all settled. Most teams have the full 5 reps, but some teams like the Giants only have 4 at this stage. Luckily the wildcard round is available for those shortchanged by the talent on their team to make a second chance run. Each division will get 4 wildcards but due to some quirks I made in the rules, they may not be from that division. This method should hopefully ensure that the best players will get in. I'll edit this post to put the current results in. The Wildcard Round should start tomorrow (today rather), probably sometime in the evening. NFC WEST 1. Justin Smith 2. Patrick Willis 3. Frank Gore 4. NaVorro Bowman 5. Carlos Rogers 1. Red Bryant 2. Brandon Mebane 3. Marshawn Lynch 4. David Hawthorne 5. Earl Thomas 1. Larry Fitzgerald 2. Calais Campbell 3. Adrian Wilson 4. Daryl Washinton 5. Chris 'Beanie' Wells 1. Chris Long 2. Steven Jackson 3. James Laurinaitis 4. Ron Bartell 5. Brandon Lloyd Wild Card Pool: Harvey Dahl Fred Robbins Danny Amendola James Hall Darnell Dockett Lyle Sendelin Kam Chancellor Chris Clemons Brandon Browner Alan Branch Vernon Davis Joe Staley Ray McDonald Aldon Smith Tarell Brown AFC EAST 1. Jake Long 2. Cameron Wake 3. Vontae Davis 4. Karlos Dansby 5. Brandon Marshall :Patriots: 1. Tom Brady 2. Rob Gronkowski 3. Vince Wilfork 4. Wes Welker 5. Jerod Mayo 1. Fred Jackson 2. Jairus Byrd 3. George Wilson 4. Nick Barnett 5. Kyle Williams 1. Darrelle Revis 2. Nick Mangold 3. D'Brickashaw Ferguson 4. David Harris 5. Santonio Holmes Wild Card Pool: Bart Scott Jim Leonhard Dustin Keller Yeremiah Bell Reggie Bush Logan Mankins Brian Waters Aaron Hernandez Sebastian Vollmer Marcel Dareus Rian Lindell Terrence McGee Steve Johnson AFC NORTH 1t. Haloti Ngata 1t. Terrell Suggs 3. Ed Reed 4. Ray Rice 1. Ben Roethlisberger 2. Troy Polamalu 3. James Harrison 4. Mike Wallace 5. LaMarr Woodley 1. Joe Thomas 2. Joe Haden 3. D'Qwell Jackson 4. Alex Mack 5. T.J. Ward 1t. Andrew Whitworth 1t. Geno Atkins 3. A.J. Green 4. Leon Hall 5. Carlos Dunlap Wild Card Pool: Jermaine Gresham Manny Lawson Thomas Howard Andy Dalton Domata Peko Nate Clements Mike Nugent Jabaal Sheard Athyba Rubin Josh Cribbs Chris Gocong Sheldon Brown Lawrence Timmons Antonio Brown Ike Taylor Brett Keisel Antonio Brown Maurkice Pouncey Ray Lewis Marshal Yanda LaDarius Webb Anquan Boldin Michael Oher Matt Birk Vonta Leach Joe Flacco NFC SOUTH 1. Aqib Talib 2. Josh Freeman 3. Gerald McCoy 4. Donald Penn 1. Jon Beason 2. Steve Smith 3. Ryan Kalil 4. Johnathan Stewart 5. Charles Johnson 1. Brent Grimes 2. Roddy White 3. Sean Weatherspoon 4. Matt Ryan 5. Curtis Lofton 1. Drew Brees 2. Carl Nicks 3. Jahri Evans 4. Jimmy Graham 5. Darren Sproles Wild Card Pool: Marques Colston Johnathan Vilma Johnathan Babineaux John Abraham Michael Turner Tony Gonzalez Tyson Clabo Cam Newton James Anderson Jordan Gross Adrian Clayborn LeGarrette Blount Davin Joseph Ronde Barber Brian Price Michael Bennett DaQuan Bowers NFC NORTH 1. Adrian Peterson 2. Jared Allen 3. Chad Greenway 4. Kevin Williams 5. Antoine Winfield 1. Aaron Rodgers 2. Greg Jennings 3. Clay Matthews 4. Charles Woodson 5. Tramon Williams 1. Calvin Johnson 2. Matt Stafford 3. Ndamukong Suh 4. Stephen Tulloch 5. Brandon Pettigrew 1. Matt Forte 2. Julius Peppers 3. Charles Tillman 4. Lance Briggs 5. Brian Urlacher Wild Card Pool: Jay Cutler Devin Hester Cliff Avril Louis Delmas Chris Houston Bryan Bulaga Jordy Nelson Scott Wells B.J. Raji Jermichael Finley Percy Harvin Ryan Longwell AFC SOUTH 1. Peyton Manning 2. Robert Mathis 3. Dwight Freeney 4. Reggie Wayne 5. Antoine Bethea 1. Maurice Jones-Drew 2. Daryl Smith 3. Terrance Knighton 4. Paul Posluszny 5. Dawan Landry 1. Cortland Finnegan 2. David Stewart 3. Michael Roos 4. Chris Johnson 5. Kenny Britt 1. Andre Johnson 2. Mario Williams 3. Arian Foster 4. Johnathan Joseph 5. Matt Schaub Wild Card Pool: Chris Myers Duane Brown Owen Daniels JJ Watt Connor Barwin Josh Scobee Jeremy Mincey Mercedes Lewis Clint Session Derek Cox Greg Jones Rob Bironas Michael Griffin Karl Klug Jason Jones Jeff Saturday Dallas Clark Pat Angerer AFC WEST 1. Jamaal Charles 2. Tamba Hali 3. Brandon Flowers 4. Derrick Johnson 5. Dwayne Bowe 1. Philip Rivers 2. Eric Weddle 3. Vincent Jackson 4. Shaun Phillips 5. Antonio Gates 1. Champ Bailey 2. Von Miller 3. Elvis Dumervil 4. Ryan Clady 5. Broderick Bunkley 1. Darren McFadden 2. Kamerion Wimbley 3. Richard Seymour 4. LaMarr Houston 5. Stanford Routt Wild Card Pool: Tyvon Branch Michael Bush Brandon Carr Eric Berry Willis McGahee D.J. Williams Ryan Mathews Antonio Garay Luis Castillo NFC East 1. London Fletcher-Baker 2. Santana Moss 3. LaRon Landry 4. Josh Wilson 5. Brian Orakpo 1. LeSean McCoy 2. Trent Cole 3. Jason Peters 4. Evan Mathis 5. Asante Samuel 1. DeMarcus Ware 2. Tony Romo 3. Jason Witten 4t. Sean Lee 4t. Jay Ratliff 1. Eli Manning 2. Jason Pierre Paul 3. Kenny Phillips 4. Justin Tuck Wild Card Pool: Mathias Kiwanuka Hakeem Nicks Victor Cruz Chris Snee Ahmad Bradshaw Osi Umenyoira Fred Davis Ryan Kerrigan Chris Cooley Tyron Smith Miles Austin Mike Jenkins DeMarco Murray Jeremy Maclin Jason Babin Nnamdi Asomugha Michael Vick Brent Celek Edited January 20, 2012 by RazorStar They're all up! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted January 20, 2012 (edited) And here are the divisions for the Round Robin Portion of the tournament. Obviously there are some unfilled names there, that won't be placed until the wildcard rounds are done. :Patriots: Tom Brady Nick Mangold Vontae Davis Nick Barnett Jerod Mayo Brian Waters Darrelle Revis Cameron Wake George Wilson Wes Welker Santonio Holmes Bart Scott Jake Long Jairus Byrd Vince Wilfork David Harris Brandon Marshall Logan Mankins Fred Jackson Rob Gronkowski D'Brickashaw Ferguson Karlos Dansby Kyle Williams Aaron Hernandez Haloti Ngata Troy Polamalu AJ Green Alex Mack Chris Clemons Marshal Yanda Ben Roethlisberger Geno Atkins D'Qwell Jackson Ray Rice LaMarr Woodley LaDarius Webb Andrew Whitworth Joe Haden Ed Reed Mike Wallace Carlos Dunlap Ray Lewis Joe Thomas Terrell Suggs James Harrison Leon Hall TJ Ward Lawrence Timmons Andre Johnson David Stewart Terrance Knighton Reggie Wayne Matt Schaub Duane Brown Cortland Finnegan Daryl Smith Dwight Freeney Johnathan Joseph Kenny Britt Jeff Saturday Maurice Jones-Drew Robert Mathis Arian Foster Chris Johnson Dawan Landry J.J. Watt Peyton Manning Mario Williams Michael Roos Paul Posluszny Antoine Bethea Chris Myers Champ Bailey Eric Weddle Richard Seymour Derrick Johnson Broderick Bunkley Brandon Carr Philip Rivers Kamerion Wimbley Brandon Flowers Ryan Clady Antonio Gates Willis McGahee Darren McFadden Tamba Hali Elvis Dumervil Shaun Phillips Stanford Routt Eric Berry Jamaal Charles Von Miller Vincent Jackson LaMarr Houston Dwayne Bowe Ryan Mathews Edited January 31, 2012 by RazorStar Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted January 20, 2012 (edited) And Here is the NFC Eli Manning Trent Cole Jason Witten Josh Wilson Jason Babin Hakeem Nicks LeSean McCoy Tony Romo LaRon Landry Justin Tuck Asante Samuel Osi Umenyoira DeMarcus Ware Santana Moss Kenny Phillips Evan Mathis Sean Lee Mathias Kiwanuka London Fletcher Jason Pierre Paul Jason Peters Jay Ratliff Brian Orakpo Victor Cruz Aaron Rodgers Matt Stafford Charles Tillman Kevin Williams Tramon Williams Jordy Nelson Calvin Johnson Julius Peppers Chad Greenway Charles Woodson Brandon Pettigrew Bryan Bulaga Matt Forte Jared Allen Clay Matthews Stephen Tulloch Brian Urlacher Cliff Avril Adrian Peterson Greg Jennings Ndamukong Suh Lance Briggs Antoine Winfield Scott Wells Drew Brees Roddy White Ryan Kalil Donald Penn Darren Sproles James Anderson Brent Grimes Steve Smith Gerald McCoy Jimmy Graham Curtis Lofton Tyson Clabo Jon Beason Josh Freeman Jahri Evans Matt Ryan Charles Johnson John Abraham Aqib Talib Carl Nicks Sean Weatherspoon Johnathan Stewart Jordan Gross Tony Gonzalez Justin Smith Calais Campbell Marshawn Lynch Ronald Bartell Carlos Rogers Vernon Davis Larry Fitzgerald Brandon Mebane James Laurinaitis Navarro Bowman Beanie Wells Ray McDonald Red Bryant Steven Jackson Frank Gore Daryl Washington Earl Thomas Aldon Smith Chris Long Patrick Willis Adrian Wilson David Hawthorne Brandon Lloyd Kam Chancellor So share your thoughts, which divisions do you think will have the most intersting matchups? Edited January 31, 2012 by RazorStar Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Thanatos 2,847 Posted January 20, 2012 (edited) My initial thoughts: :Patriots: Tom Brady Darrelle Revis vs Wes Welker Jake Long vs Brandon Marshall Rob Gronkowski Haloti Ngata vs Troy Polamalu Ben Roethlisberger vs Ray Rice Ed Reed vs Mike Wallace Joe Thomas vs Terrell Suggs Andre Johnson vs Reggie Wayne vs Matt Schaub Cortland Finnegan vs Johnathan Joseph Maurice Jones-Drew vs Arian Foster Peyton Manning- He was on IR all year, though, so if this is purely 2012, then my second choice would be Paul Posluszny. Derrick Johnson Philip Rivers vs Brandon Flowers vs Antonio Gates Darren McFadden vs Tamba Hali Von Miller vs Vincent Jackson Eli Manning vs Trent Cole vs Jason Witten LeSean McCoy vs Tony Romo DeMarcus Ware London Fletcher vs Jason Pierre-Paul Aaron Rodgers Calvin Johnson vs Julius Peppers vs Charles Woodson Matt Forte vs Jared Allen Adrian Peterson vs Greg Jennings Drew Brees vs Ryan Kalil vs Darren Sproles Steve Smith vs Jimmy Graham Jon Beason- Again, however, he was injured nearly the whole of 2011. Second choice would be Jahri Evans Sean Weatherspoon Justin Smith vs Marshawn Lynch Larry Fitzgerald vs Navarro Bowman Frank Gore Patrick Willis vs Chris Long Edited January 20, 2012 by Thanatos19 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted January 29, 2012 Here are the Wildcards, along with the list of final Wild Cards. AFC North: 1. Marshal Yanda 2. Lawrence Timmons 3. Ray Lewis 4. LaDarius Webb NFC South: 1. James Anderson 2. Tony Gonzalez 3. John Abraham 4. Tyson Clabo AFC East: 1. Brian Waters 2. Aaron Hernandez 3. Logan Mankins 4. Bart Scott NFC East: 1. Hakeem Nicks 2. Victor Cruz 3. Mathias Kiwanuka 4. Osi Umenyoira NFC West: 1. Vernon Davis 2. Kam Chancellor 3. Aldon Smith AFC South: 1. Duane Brown 2. Chris Myers 3. J.J. Watt 4. Jeff Saturday NFC North: 1. Jordy Nelson 2. Scott Wells 3. Cliff Avril 4. Bryan Bulaga AFC West: 1. Brandon Carr 2. Ryan Mathews 3. Eric Berry 4. Willis McGahee And here are the players remaining for Final Wild Card Voting. There are 4 spots to fill for these guys, Bucs 5, Giants 5, Ravens 5, and NFC West Wild Card 4. Anquan Boldin Jordan Gross Marques Colston Cam Newton Steve Johnson Jim Leonhard Jason Babin Tyron Smith Nnamdi Asomugha Joe Staley Ray McDonald Chris Clemons Tarell Brown Owen Daniels Dallas Clark Jay Cutler Percy Harvin Antonio Garay Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted January 31, 2012 The round robin divisions are now complete. I probably won't start the round robin until the super bowl has been played, if only so I can kick if off during the off-season. As you can expect, each player in a division will play each other player in that division once. After 24 hours the polls close. Wins, Losses, and Draws are all acceptable results. Once each player has faced off in his 5 matches, the records are tallied up and the top two players in each division move on. I have been considering the top three, but unless I get some good feedback for it, I'll just go with the top two. Tiebreakers will be settled in this order: 1. Head 2 Head (should cover most situations) 2. Vote Differential (should cover the rest) 3. 24 hour head to head sudden death match. 4. If tiebreaker 3 still results in a tie after 24 hours, the next vote will settle it. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted January 31, 2012 Now then, I have the round robin schedule whipped up. Each person in the division can be numbered for 1 to 6, 1 at the top and 6 at the bottom. When you count like this, the round robin schedule looks like this for each division. Match 1: 1 v. 2 3 v. 4 5 v. 6 Match 2: 1 v. 3 2 v. 6 4 v. 5 Match 3: 1 v. 4 2 v. 5 3 v. 6 Match 4: 1 v. 5 2 v. 3 4 v. 6 Match 5: 1 v. 6 2 v. 4 3 v. 5 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted February 1, 2012 My predictions for the survivors of the round robin. :Patriots: 1. Tom Brady 2. Nick Mangold 1. Darelle Revis 2. Cameron Wake 1. Jake Long 2. Vince Wilfork 1. Rob Gronkowski 2. Fred Jackson 1. Troy Polamalu 2. Haloti Ngata 3. Marshal Yanda (have a feeling this one will be close) 1. Ben Roethlisberger 2. I'm leaning Ray Rice but... 1. Andrew Whitworth 2. Ed Reed 1. James Harrison 2. Joe Thomas 1. Andre Johnson 2. David Stewart 1. Johnathan Joseph 2. Daryl Smith 1. Maurice Jones-Drew 2. Arian Foster Toss up here, but I think Peyton would have the edge due to past experience. 1. Eric Weddle 2. Derrick Johnson 1. Philip Rivers 2. Brandon Flowers 1. Tamba Hali 2. Darren McFadden 1. Jamaal Charles 2. Von Miller 1. Trent Cole 2. Eli Manning 1. Tony Romo 2. LeSean McCoy 1. DeMarcus Ware 2. Kenny Phillips (close) 1. London Fletcher 2. Jason Pierre-Paul 1. Aaron Rodgers 2. Charles Tillman 1. Calvin Johnson 2. Julius Peppers 1. Jared Allen 2. Matt Forte 1. Adrian Peterson 2. Antoine Winfield 1. Drew Brees 2. Roddy White 1. Jimmy Graham 2. Brent Grimes 1. Jahri Evans 2. Charles Johnson 1. Carl Nicks 2. Sean Weatherspoon 1. Justin Smith 2. Calais Campbell 1. Larry Fitzgerald 2. Brandon Mebane 1. Red Bryant 2. Daryl Washington 1. Patrick Willis 2. Chris Long Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted February 8, 2012 Results: Day 1 DeMarcus Ware 9 Santana Moss 0 Kenny Phillips 3 Evan Mathis 6 Sean Lee 6 Mathias Kiwanuka 3 Cortland Finnegan 5 Daryl Smith 4 Dwight Freeney 1 Johnathan Joseph 8 Kenny Britt 3 Jeff Saturday 6 Chris Long 1 Patrick Willis 8 Adrian Wilson 7 David Hawthorne 2 Brandon Lloyd 1 Kam Chancellor 8 Darelle Revis 9 Cameron Wake 0 George Wilson 3 Wes Welker 6 Santonio Holmes 2 Bart Scott 7 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted February 9, 2012 Results: Day 2 Red Bryant 4 Steven Jackson 8 Frank Gore 10 Dary Washington 2 Earl Thomas 7 Aldon Smith 5 Jamaal Charles 3 Von Miller 9 Vincent Jackson 9 LaMarr Houston 3 Dwayne Bowe 10 Ryan Mathews 2 Darren McFadden 2 Tamba Hali 10 Elvis Dumervil 11 Shaun Phillips 1 Stanford Routt 10 Eric Berry 2 Adrian Peterson 8 Greg Jennings 2 Ndamukong Suh 0 Lance Briggs 10 Antoine Winfield 7 Scott Wells 3 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted February 10, 2012 Results: Day 3 London Fletcher 3 Jason Pierre-Paul 5 Jason Peters 8 Jay Ratliff 0 Brian Orakpo 3 Victor Cruz 5 Champ Bailey 8 Eric Weddle 2 Richard Seymour 2 Derrick Johnson 8 Broderick Bunkley 3 Brandon Carr 7 Jon Beason 10 Josh Freeman 0 Jahri Evans 9 Matt Ryan 1 Charles Johnson 9 John Abraham 1 LeSean McCoy 9 Tony Romo 1 LaRon Landry 0 Justin Tuck 10 Asante Samuel 5 Osi Umenyoira 5 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted February 10, 2012 That's right we've got our first tie of the round robin. I'm using World Cup scoring rules, so Wins get 3 points, ties get 1, and losses get 0. So basically it's better to go (W-L-D) 2-2-1 than it is 1-1-3 even if those are both .500 records. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Vin+ 3,121 Posted February 10, 2012 Results: Day 1 Cortland Finnegan 5 Daryl Smith 4 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted February 11, 2012 (edited) Results: Day 4 Peyton Manning 2 Mario Williams 7 Michael Roos 7 Paul Posluszny 2 Antoine Bethea 0 Chris Myers 9 :Patriots: Tom Brady 9 Nick Mangold 0 Vontae Davis 9 Nick Barnett 0 Jerod Mayo 0 Brian Waters 9 Jake Long 10 Jairus Byrd 0 Vince Wilfork 10 David Harris 0 Brandon Marshall 8 Logan Mankins 2 Philip Rivers 10 Kam Wimbley 0 Brandon Flowers 10 Ryan Clady 0 Antonio Gates 9 Willis McGahee 1 Edited February 12, 2012 by RazorStar Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Thanatos 2,847 Posted February 12, 2012 Antonio Gates 9 Ryan Clady 1 Should be Willis McGahee 1, not Ryan Clady. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted February 12, 2012 Thanks for the heads up Thanatos. That's corrected, and here are the day 5 results. We had another tie. Results: Day 5 Andre Johnson 8 David Stewart 0 Terrance Knighton 2 Reggie Wayne 6 Matt Schaub 8 Duane Brown 0 Justin Smith 8 Calais Campbell 0 Marshawn Lynch 7 Ronald Bartell 1 Carlos Rogers 2 Vernon Davis 6 Larry Fitzgerald 8 Brandon Mebane 0 James Laurinaitis 1 NaVarro Bowman 7 Chris Wells 1 Ray McDonald 7 Matt Forte 7 Jared Allen 1 Clay Matthews 4 Stephen Tulloch 4 Brian Urlacher 5 Cliff Avril 3 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted February 13, 2012 Results: Day 6 Aaron Rodgers 10 Matt Stafford 1 Charles Tillman 7 Kevin Williams 4 Tramon Williams 3 Jordy Nelson 8 Haloti Ngata 6 Troy Polamalu 3 AJ Green 3 Alex Mack 6 Chris Clemons 2 Marshal Yanda 7 Fred Jackson 2 Rob Gronkowski 8 D'Brickashaw Ferguson 6 Karlos Dansby 4 Kyle Williams 7 Aaron Hernandez 3 Andrew Whitworth 1 Joe Haden 9 Ed Reed 6 Mike Wallace 4 Carlos Dunlap 2 Ray Lewis 8 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted February 14, 2012 Day 7: Results Maurice Jones-Drew 11 Robert Mathis 0 Arian Foster 11 Chris Johnson 0 Dawan Landry 1 JJ Watt 10 Joe Thomas 4 Terrell Suggs 7 James Harrison 9 Leon Hall 2 T.J. Ward 2 Lawrence Timmons 9 Ben Roethlisberger 9 Geno Atkins 2 D'Qwell Jackson 1 Ray Rice 10 LaMarr Woodley 5 LaDarius Webb 6 Eli Manning 9 Trent Cole 2 Jason Witten 11 Josh Wilson 0 Jason Babin 2 Hakeem Nicks 9 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted February 15, 2012 Results: Day 8 Drew Brees 8 Roddy White 1 Ryan Kalil 9 Donald Penn 0 Darren Sproles 6 James Anderson 3 Brent Grimes 7 Steve Smith 2 Gerald McCoy 0 Jimmy Graham 9 Curtis Lofton 3 Tyson Clabo 6 Calvin Johnson 8 Julius Peppers 0 Chad Greenway 2 Charles Woodson 6 Brandon Pettigrew 1 Bryan Bulaga 7 Aqib Talib 0 Carl Nicks 8 Sean Weatherspoon 2 Johnathan Stewart 6 Jordan Gross 4 Tony Gonzalez 4 We've reached the point where every competitior has concluded their first match. Only 32 more days to go. We've had yet another tie which makes our 3rd one in 8 days. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
