RazorStar 4,025 Posted November 30, 2016 The top ten finally got shaken up a bit. And by that I mean Cousins and Mariota have finally pulled ahead of Matt Stafford. Brian Hoyer is acting as a human buffer between MVP candidate level play and streaky guys with flashes of brilliance. There wasn't much movement this week, Ryan Tannehill being the largest riser going up 5 spots, and Andy Dalton falls down at the same rate. That's what losing AJ Green and Gio Bernard will do to a guy I guess. If you were to rank the QB's whose teams would currently have a playoff berth you've got 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 8, 12, 14, 19, 20, 28 and 34. Good ol AFC South and Brock Osweiler. I mean it bodes better for the Titans and Steelers when the end of the year comes around, but they have to win the games they're supposed to. Week 12 QB Rankings 1. Tom Brady 9 2. Dak Prescott 14 3. Drew Brees 21 (+1) 4. Matt Ryan 23 (-1) 5. Derek Carr 35 6. Kirk Cousins 36 (+1) 7. Marcus Mariota 38 (+1) 8. Matt Stafford 39 (-2) 9. Brian Hoyer 46 10. Aaron Rodgers 52 (+1) 11. Ben Roethlisberger 56 (+1) 12. Ryan Tannehill 59 (+5) 13. Sam Bradford 61 (+2) 14. Russell Wilson 63 (-4) 15. Tyrod Taylor 66 (+3) 16. Andrew Luck 68 (-2) 17. Philip Rivers 70 (+2) 18. Andy Dalton 72 (-5) 19. Alex Smith 74 (-3) 20. Eli Manning 78 21. Colin Kaepernick 81 (+2) 22. Jameis Winston 81 (-1) 23. Trevor Siemian 85 (+1) 24. Cam Newton 85 (-2) 25. Cody Kessler 92 26. Blaine Gabbert 97 27. Blake Bortles 99 28. Joe Flacco 104 (+2) 29. Carson Wentz 105 (-1) 30. Carson Palmer 109 (-1) 31. Case Keenum 114 32. Jay Cutler 119 33. Ryan Fitzpatrick 120 (+2) 34. Brock Osweiler 122 (-1) 35. Josh McCown 127 (-1) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted December 9, 2016 (edited) Week 13 numbers before I forget: 1. Tom Brady 14 2. Dak Prescott 15 3. Matt Ryan 26 (+1) 4. Drew Brees 30 (-1) 5. Matt Stafford 34 (+3) 6. Derek Carr 34 (-1) 7. Marcus Mariota 37 8. Kirk Cousins 40 (-2) 9. Brian Hoyer 49 10. Aaron Rodgers 51 11. Andrew Luck 52 (+5) 12. Ben Roethlisberger 54 (-1) 13. Andy Dalton 60 (+5) 14. Sam Bradford 64 (-1) 15. Russell Wilson 65 (-1) 16. Alex Smith 65 (+3) 17. Philip Rivers 70 18. Ryan Tannehill 75 (-6) 19. Tyrod Taylor 75 (-4) 20. Jameis Winston 78 (+2) 21. Trevor Siemian 84 (+2) 22. Eli Manning 84 (-2) 23. Colin Kaepernick 85 (-2) 24. Cam Newton 87 25. Joe Flacco 87 (+3) 26. Cody Kessler 92 (-1) 27. Blaine Gabbert 101 (-1) 28. Blake Bortles 102 (-1) 29. Carson Palmer 103 (+1) 30. Carson Wentz 112 (-1) 31. Case Keenum 114 32. Brock Osweiler 114 (+2) 33. Ryan Fitzpatrick 119 34. Jay Cutler 120 (-2) 35. Josh McCown 128 Edited December 9, 2016 by RazorStar Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted December 16, 2016 Well the top is finally shifting a little. Maybe Aaron Rodgers has finally figured out how to escape his slump, because he's climbing the leaderboard rapidly. He would need a lot of help to get to the very top spot, but stranger things have happened. Ryan Tannehill ends his best season on a sour note, as his ACL injury is gonna be costly for a competitive Dolphins team. Kirk Cousins has made a name for himself in the top 5, and we have two new QB's to qualify for the rankings at this late stage. Too bad they're both pretty clearly fodder. Also RIP Russell Wilson's dignity. Somehow he only fell 6 spots with that shameful performance. Week 14 Rankings 1. Tom Brady 9 2. Matt Ryan 18 (+1) 3. Dak Prescott 28 (-1) 4. Kirk Cousins 34 (+4) 5. Drew Brees 34 (-1) 6. Matt Stafford 40 (-1) 7. Aaron Rodgers 40 (+3) 8. Marcus Mariota 42 (-1) 9. Derek Carr 47 (-3) 10. Brian Hoyer 48 (-1) 11. Andrew Luck 56 12. Ben Roethlisberger 57 13. Andy Dalton 58 14. Sam Bradford 58 15. Alex Smith 62 (+1) 16. Ryan Tannehill 64 (+2) 17. Tyrod Taylor 72 (+2) 18. Jameis Winston 76 (+2) 19. Philip Rivers 77 (-2) 20. Trevor Siemian 79 (+1) 21. Russell Wilson 81 (-6) 22. Joe Flacco 85 (+3) 23. Eli Manning 87 (-1) 24. Colin Kaepernick 90 (-1) 25. Cam Newton 91 (-1) 26. Cody Kessler 92 27. Blake Bortles 99 (+1) 28. Blaine Gabbert 100 (-1) 29. Carson Palmer 111 30. Carson Wentz 112 31. Case Keenum 113 32. Matt Barkley 118 (NR) 33. Brock Osweiler 122 (-1) 34. Jay Cutler 124 35. Ryan Fitzpatrick 124 (-2) 36. Jared Goff 129 (NR) 37. Josh McCown 135 (-2) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted December 23, 2016 I need to stop forgetting to update this. Tommy boy is still the king. Week 15 QB Rankings 1. Tom Brady 14 2. Matt Ryan 15 3. Dak Prescott 23 4. Drew Brees 29 (+1) 5. Kirk Cousins 39 (-1) 6. Matt Stafford 40 7. Aaron Rodgers 42 8. Marcus Mariota 47 9. Brian Hoyer 47 (+1) 10. Derek Carr 47 (-1) 11. Andrew Luck 51 12. Ben Roethlisberger 57 13. Ryan Tannehill 64 (+3) 14. Andy Dalton 64 (-1) 15. Sam Bradford 65 (-1) 16. Tyrod Taylor 65 (+1) 17. Alex Smith 66 (-2) 18. Russell Wilson 70 (+3) 19. Philip Rivers 78 20. Jameis Winston 82 (-2) 21. Trevor Siemian 83 (-1) 22. Eli Manning 83 (+1) 23. Colin Kaepernick 86 (+1) 24. Joe Flacco 88 (-2) 25. Cam Newton 90 26. Cody Kessler 94 27. Carson Palmer 100 (+2) 28. Matt Barkley 104 (+4) 29. Blake Bortles 104 (-2) 30. Blaine Gabbert 104 (-2) 31. Case Keenum 116 32. Carson Wentz 118 (-2) 33. Jay Cutler 125 (+1) 34. Ryan Fitzpatrick 126 (+1) 35. Brock Osweiler 126 (-2) 36. Josh McCown 134 (+1) 37. Jared Goff 136 (-1) 38. Bryce Petty 142 (NR) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Cherry 1,302 Posted December 23, 2016 I'd like to note that Kessler is better than Wentz and Goff according to your spreadsheet. :^) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted December 27, 2016 All hail our glorious overlord Aaron Rodgers, who has returned to the top 5 in spectacular fashion. And all laugh at Trevor Siemian, who tumbles down 7 spots in the biggest fall of the week. Marcus Mariota and Derek Carr's seasons end in tragic fashion, but while Carr will end his season in the top 10, Mariota falls out with his latest performance. Tough break, Titans Fans. Matt Stafford also fell outside of the top ten for the second time this season, but he has one game against the Packers to show he deserves to be up there. Bobby G Tres makes his first appearance since week 1, and hasn't done much to chance his standing. At least he won a game, that's good. The race to the top is between Matt Ryan and Tom Brady. Brady hasn't relinquished the spot since he qualified for the rankings, but Ryan has been hot on his heels all season long. Can the Dolphins ailing D do enough to contain him? Ha Ha Ha. Week 16 QB Rankings: 1. Tom Brady 14 2. Matt Ryan 15 3. Dak Prescott 19 4. Drew Brees 32 5. Aaron Rodgers 35 (+2) 6. Kirk Cousins 37 (-1) 7. Derek Carr 45 (+3) 8. Brian Hoyer 47 (+1) 9. Andrew Luck 51 (+2) 10. Ben Roethlisberger 54 (+2) 11. Matt Stafford 54 (-5) 12. Marcus Mariota 55 (-4) 13. Tyrod Taylor 55 (+3) 14. Sam Bradford 61 (+1) 15. Ryan Tannehill 64 (-2) 16. Russell Wilson 64 (+2) 17. Alex Smith 66 18. Andy Dalton 73 (-4) 19. Philip Rivers 80 20. Colin Kaepernick 80 (+3) 21. Jameis Winston 83 (-1) 22. Eli Manning 90 23. Joe Flacco 90 (+1) 24. Cody Kessler 95 (+2) 25. Cam Newton 95 26. Matt Barkley 96 (+2) 27. Carson Palmer 97 28. Trevor Siemian 99 (-7) 29. Blake Bortles 102 30. Blaine Gabbert 105 31. Carson Wentz 117 (+1) 32. Case Keenum 118 (-1) 33. Jay Cutler 124 34. Brock Osweiler 125 (+1) 35. Robert Griffin 125 (NR) 36. Ryan Fitzpatrick 133 (-2) 37. Josh McCown 135 (-1) 38. Jared Goff 144 (-1) 39. Bryce Petty 146 (-1) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Cherry 1,302 Posted December 27, 2016 Cody > Cam :^) Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted January 2, 2017 Well it took until the last game of the season, but Matt Ryan has finally dethroned Tom Brady, and retaken the top spot on my rankings. Eat shit, Patriots. 2016 WEEK 17 QB Rankings 1. Matt Ryan 11 (+1) 2. Tom Brady 13 (-1) 3. Dak Prescott 20 4. Drew Brees 30 5. Aaron Rodgers 33 6. Kirk Cousins 40 7. Derek Carr 44 8. Brian Hoyer 48 9. Andrew Luck 54 10. Matt Stafford 54 (+1) 11. Marcus Mariota 55 (+1) 12. Ben Roethlisberger 56 (-2) 13. Tyrod Taylor 57 14. Alex Smith 59 (+3) 15. Sam Bradford 59 (-1) 16. Russell Wilson 63 17. Ryan Tannehill 65 (-2) 18. Andy Dalton 68 19. Colin Kaepernick 78 (+1) 20. Philip Rivers 82 (-1) 21. Jameis Winston 86 22. Eli Manning 91 23. Joe Flacco 92 24. Trevor Siemian 95 (+4) 25. Carson Palmer 96 (+2) 26. Cody Kessler 96 (-2) 27. Matt Barkley 99 (-1) 28. Cam Newton 100 (-3) 29. Blake Bortles 101 30. Blaine Gabbert 107 31. Carson Wentz 113 32. Case Keenum 120 33. Robert Griffin 123 (+2) 34. Brock Osweiler 125 35. Ryan Fitzpatrick 127 (+1) 36. Jay Cutler 128 (-3) 37. Josh McCown 137 38. Jared Goff 147 39. Bryce Petty 148 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bay 2,003 Posted January 2, 2017 Cody > Cam :^) Cody> Nam Scewton Share this post Link to post Share on other sites