SteVo+ 3,702 Posted February 12, 2018 Our journey toward naming the best player in football begins with our Divisional Round, where we list the best players on each team. Remember you're identifying the best players in the NFL right now, so performance in the 2017 season should be a principal factor but not the only factor. Here's how it works: For each team, nominate who you think are the six best players on their roster, assigning +6 points to the best player, +5 points to the second-best player, and so on. Assemble a top 6 for all four teams in the AFC East. Feel free to discuss/debate the rankings of others; that's part of the fun of this process. At the risk of influencing the vote, here are my picks: +6 Tom Brady +5 Rob Gronkowski +4 Nate Solder +3 Stephon Gilmore +2 Julian Edelman (Don't forget about him because he was hurt this year!) +1 Dion Lewis +6 LeSean McCoy +5 Tre'Davious White +4 Richie Incognito +3 Kyle Williams +2 Micah Hyde +1 Jerry Hughes +6 Ndamukong Suh +5 Jarvis Landry +4 Ryan Tannehill +3 Cameron Wake +2 Mike Pouncey +1 Kiko Alonso +6 Leonard Williams +5 Demario Davis +4 Jamal Adams +3 Josh McCown +2 Steve McLendon +1 Robby Anderson Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Thanatos 2,847 Posted February 12, 2018 (edited) +6 Tom Brady +5 Rob Gronkowski +4 Julian Edelman +3 Malcolm Butler +2 James White +1 Dion Lewis +6 LeSean McCoy +5 TreDavious White +4 Kyle Williams +3 Jerry Hughes +2 Richie Incognito +1 Tyrod Taylor +6 Jarvis Landry +5 Ndamukong Suh +4 Cameron Wake +3 Kenyan Drake +2 Ryan Tannehill +1 Kiko Alonso +6 Leonard Williams +5 Robby Anderson +4 Jamal Adams +3 Quincy Enunwa +2 Demario Davis +1 Marcus Maye Edited February 12, 2018 by Thanatos Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted February 12, 2018 +6 Devin McCourty +5 Rob Gronkowski +4 Tom Brady +3 David Andrews +2 Malcolm Butler +1 Donta Hightower +6 Ndamukong Suh +5 Cameron Wake +4 Reshad Jones +3 Jarvis Landry +2 Mike Pouncey +1 Kiko Alonso +6 LeSean McCoy +5 Micah Hyde +4 Preston Brown +3 Eric Wood (RIP his career) +2 TreDavious White +1 Steven Hauschka +6 Leonard Williams +5 Muhammad Wilkerson +4 Jamal Adams +3 Kony Ealy +2 Marcus Maye +1 Robby Anderson Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
56AceInDaPlace 110 Posted February 12, 2018 +6 Tom Brady +5 Rob Gronkowski +4 Devin McCourty +3 Trey Flowers +2 Julian Edelman +1 Shaq Mason +6 Ndamukong Suh +5 Cameron Wake +4 Reshad Jones +3 Jarvis Landry +2 Mike Pouncey +1 Kiko Alonso +6 LeSean McCoy +5 Micah Hyde +4 Rich Incognito +3 Tre White (CB) +2 Kyle Williams +1 Preston Brown +6 Leonard Williams +5 Muhammad Wilkerson +4 Jamal Adams +3 Jermaine Kearse +2 Marcus Maye +1 Robby Anderson Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BJORN 679 Posted February 12, 2018 +6 Leo Williams +5 Muhammed Wilkerson +4 Jamal Adams +3 Demario Davis +2 Marcus Maye +1 Robby Anderson +6 Ndamukong Suh +5 Reshad Jones +4 Cameron Wake +3 Jarvis Landry +2 Kiko Alonso +1 Lawrence Timmons +6 LeSean McCoy +5 Tre'Davious White +4 Preston Brown +3 Jerry Hughes +2 Micah Hyde +1 Richie Incognito +6 Tom Brady +5 Rob Gronkowski +4 Nate Solder +3 Malcolm Butler +2 Brandin Cooks +1 Stephen Gostkowski Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
WeaponX20 26 Posted February 12, 2018 Patriots +6 Gronk +5 Brady +4 Donta Hightower + 3 Julian Eldman +2 Devin Mcourty + 1 Nate Solder Bills +6 LeSean McCoy +5 Tradvious White +4 Richie Icgonito +3 Micah Hyde +2 Jerry Hughes +1 Kyle Willams Dolphins +6 ReShad Jones +5 Ndamukong Suh +4 Jarvis Landry +3 Cameron Wake +2 Ryan Tannehill +1 Kiko Alonso Jets +6 Leonard Willams +5 Jamal Adams +4 Mumuhad Wilkerson +3 Josh Mccown +2 Jevon Kearse +1 Marcus Maye Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Packers Dynasty 2010 116 Posted February 12, 2018 (edited) +6 Tom Brady +5 Rob Gronkowski +4 Devin McCourty +3 Nate Solder +2 Julian Edelmen +1 Malcolm Butler +6 Lesean McCoy +5 Tre'Davious White +4 Micah Hyde +3 Richie Incognito +2 Kyle Williams +1 Jerry Hughes +6 Reshad Jones +5 Ndamukong Sug +4 Jarvis Landry +3 Cameron Wake +2 Mike Pouncey +1 Xavien Howard +6 Leonard Williams +5 Muhammed Wilkerson +4 Jamal Adams +3 Demario Davis +2 Marcus Maye +1 Robby Anderson Edited February 12, 2018 by Packers Dynasty 2010 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SteVo+ 3,702 Posted February 12, 2018 It's early but I can't resist tallying up the votes. Current through PD2010. Tom Brady 39 Rob Gronkowski 36 Devin McCourty 16 Julian Edelman 13 Nate Solder 12 ----- Malcolm Butler 9 Donta Hightower 5 David Andrews 3 Stephon Gilmore 3 Trey Flowers 3 Brandin Cooks 2 Dion Lewis 2 James White 2 Shaq Mason 1 Stephen Gostkowski 1 LeSean McCoy 42 Tre'Davious White 30 Micah Hyde 21 Richie Incognito 18 Kyle Williams 12 ----- Jerry Hughes 10 Preston Brown 9 Eric Wood 3 Tyrod Taylor 1 Steven Hauschka 1 Ndamukong Suh 39 Jarvis Landry 28 Cameron Wake 27 Reshad Jones 25 t-Ryan Tannehill 8 t-Mike Pouncey 8 ----- Kiko Alonso 7 Kenyan Drake 3 Lawrence Timmons 1 Xavien Howard 1 Leonard Williams 42 Jamal Adams 29 Muhammad Wilkerson 24 Demario Davis 13 t-Robby Anderson 10 t-Marcus Maye 10 ----- Josh McCown 6 Jermaine Kearse 5 Kony Ealy 3 Quincy Enunwa 3 Steve McLendon 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BJORN 679 Posted February 13, 2018 I am surprised many people are taking Edelman over Cooks. I think it is pretty close between the two but on here it is a landslide in favor of Edelman. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SteVo+ 3,702 Posted February 13, 2018 I am surprised many people are taking Edelman over Cooks. I think it is pretty close between the two but on here it is a landslide in favor of Edelman. I feel like Edelman becomes the steady feature of the passing game (besides Gronk), a role Cooks never quite filled. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Thanatos 2,847 Posted February 13, 2018 Cooks is not close to as good as Edelman IMO. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
seanbrock 1,684 Posted February 14, 2018 Brady +6 Gronk +5 McCourty +4 Butler +3 Solder +2 Andrews +1 McCoy +6 Hughes +5 Hyde +4 White +3 Williams +2 Wood +1 Williams +6 Wilkerson +5 Adams +4 Anderson +3 Davis +2 Enunwa +1 Suh +6 Landry +5 Wake +4 Jones +3 Pouncey +2 Alonso +1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Cherry 1,302 Posted February 15, 2018 +6 Tom Brady +5 Rob Gronkowski +4 Stephon Gilmore +3 Julian Edelman +2 Devin McCourty +1 D'onta Hightower +6 Ndamukong Suh +5 Cameron Wake +4 Reshad Jones +3 Kiko Alonso +2 Mike Pouncey +1 Jarvis Landry +6 LeSean McCoy +5 Richie Incognito +4 Tre'Davious White +3 Eric Wood (RIP) +2 Cordy Glenn +1 Micah Hyde +6 Leonard Williams +5 Mo Wilkerson +4 Jamal Adams +3 Robbie Anderson +2 Demario Davis +1 Josh McCown 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SteVo+ 3,702 Posted February 17, 2018 If you haven't voted yet, today is your last chance! We'll be closing this sometime tonight or tomorrow morning. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Omerta+ 1,206 Posted February 17, 2018 Patriots +6 Rob Gronkowski +5 Puss cakes +4 Devin McCourty +3 Nate Solder +2 Stephon Gilmore +1 Malcolm Butler Jets +6 Leonard Williams+5 Mo Wilkerson+4 Jamal Adams+3 Robbie Anderson+2 Demario Davis+1 Josh McCown Bills McCoy +6 Hughes +5 Hyde +4 White +3 Williams +2 Wood +1 Dolphins +6 Reshad Jones +5 Ndamukong Sug +4 Jarvis Landry +3 Cameron Wake +2 Mike Pouncey +1 X. Howard Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SteVo+ 3,702 Posted February 18, 2018 Voting is closed. Final results: Tom Brady 56 Rob Gronkowski 52 Devin McCourty 26 Nate Solder 17 Julian Edelman 16 ----- Malcolm Butler 13 Stephon Gilmore 9 Donta Hightower 6 David Andrews 4 Trey Flowers 3 Brandin Cooks 2 Dion Lewis 2 James White 2 Shaq Mason 1 Stephen Gostkowski 1 LeSean McCoy 60 Tre'Davious White 40 Micah Hyde 30 Richie Incognito 23 Jerry Hughes 20 ----- Kyle Williams 16 Preston Brown 9 Eric Wood 8 Cordy Glenn 2 Tyrod Taylor 1 Steven Hauschka 1 Ndamukong Suh 56 Cameron Wake 39 Jarvis Landry 38 Reshad Jones 38 Mike Pouncey 14 ----- Kiko Alonso 11 Ryan Tannehill 8 Kenyan Drake 3 Xavien Howard 2 Lawrence Timmons 1 Leonard Williams 60 Jamal Adams 41 Muhammad Wilkerson 40 Demario Davis 19 Robby Anderson 19 ----- Marcus Maye 10 Josh McCown 8 Jermaine Kearse 5 Quincy Enunwa 4 Kony Ealy 3 Steve McLendon 2 All top-5 players advance to the Elimination Round. All other players receiving votes advance to the Wild Card Round. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites