SteVo+ 3,702 Posted February 16, 2018 Our journey toward naming the best player in football begins with our Divisional Round, where we list the best players on each team. Remember you're identifying the best players in the NFL right now, so performance in the 2017 season should be a principal factor but not the only factor. Here's how it works: For each team, nominate who you think are the six best players on their roster, assigning +6 points to the best player, +5 points to the second-best player, and so on. Assemble a top 6 for all four teams in the NFC South. Feel free to discuss/debate the rankings of others; that's part of the fun of this process. My picks: +6 Drew Brees +5 Cameron Jordan +4 Marshon Lattimore +3 Michael Thomas +2 Alvin Kamara +1 Ryan Ramczyk +6 Luke Kuechly +5 Kawann Short +4 Andrew Norwell +3 Cam Newton +2 Daryl Williams +1 Greg Olsen +6 Matt Ryan +5 Julio Jones +4 Alex Mack +3 Matt Bryant +2 Deion Jones +1 Keanu Neal +6 Gerald McCoy +5 Lavonte David +4 Mike Evans +3 Robert Ayers +2 Brent Grimes +1 Demar Dotson Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Packers Dynasty 2010 116 Posted February 16, 2018 +6 Drew Brees +5 Cameron Jordan +4 Michael Thomas +3 Marshon Lattimore +2 Terron Armstead +1 Alvin Kamara +6 Luke Keuchly +5 Cam Newton +4 Kawann Short +3 Greg Olsen +2 Andrew Norwell +1 Julius Peppers +6 Julio Jones +5 Matt Ryan +4 Alex Mack +3 Desmond Trufant +2 Matt Bryant +1 Deion Jones +6 Gerald McCoy +5 Mike Evans +4 Lavonte David +3 Robert Ayers +2 Kwon Alexander +1 Doug Martin Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
WeaponX20 26 Posted February 16, 2018 (edited) Saints +6 Drew Brees +5 Cameron Jordan +4 Marshawn Lattimore +3 Alvin Kamara +2 Mark Ingram ll +1 Marcus Williams Panthers +6 Luke Kuechly +5 Tomas Davis +4 Cam Newton +3 Greg Olson +2 Shaq Thompson +1 Star Lotuleli Falcons +6 Julio Jones +5 Desmond Trufant + 4 Keanu Neal +3 Devonta Freeman +2 Deion Jones +1 Matt Ryan Buccaneers +6 Mike Evans +5 Gerald Mccoy +4 Levonte David +3 Kwon Alexander +2 Doug Martin +1 Jamies Winston Edited February 16, 2018 by WeaponX20 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Thanatos 2,847 Posted February 17, 2018 +6 Drew Brees +5 Alvin Kamara +4 Marshon Lattimore +3 Cam Jordan +2 Ryan Ramzyk +1 Michael Thomas +6 Luke Kuechly +5 Cam Newton +4 Andrew Norwell +3 Kawann Short +2 Mario Addison +1 Greg Olsen +6 Mike Evans +5 Lavonte David +4 Gerald McCoy +3 Kwon Alexander +2 Robert Ayers +1 Brent Grimes +6 Julio Jones +5 Devonta Freeman +4 Keanu Neal +3 Desmond Trufant +2 Alex Mack +1 Deion Jones Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted February 17, 2018 +6 Drew Brees +5 Terron Armstead +4 Michael Thomas +3 Larry Warford +2 Cameron Jordan +1 Marshon Lattimore (Saints had a lot of guys worth considering for this list) +6 Alex Mack +5 Dontari Poe +4 Julio Jones +3 Matt Ryan +2 Deion Jones +1 Desmond Trufant (Another team with a lot of guys on the cusp, geez) +6 Luke Kuechly +5 Kawaan Short +4 Andrew Norwell +3 Greg Olsen +2 Trai Turner +1 Cam Newton (I'm actually good with this, there might be a coupla 30+ year old guys on the cusp, but eh) +6 Demar Dotson +5 Gerald McCoy +4 Lavonte David +3 Mike Evans +2 Chris Baker +1 Kwon Alexander Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Cherry 1,302 Posted February 18, 2018 +6 Drew Brees +5 Marshon Lattimore +4 Michael Thomas +3 Terron Armstead +2 Cameron Jordan +1 Alvin Kamara +6 Lavonte David +5 Gerald McCoy +4 Mike Evans +3 Robert Ayers+2 Demar Dotson +1 Jameis Winston +6 Luke Kuechly +5 Cam Newton +4 Greg Olsen +3 Kawaan Short +2 Andrew Norwell +1 Shaq Thompson +6 Julio Jones +5 Matt Ryan +4 Deion Jones +3 Keanu Neal +2 Devonta Freeman +1 Alex Mack Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
seanbrock 1,684 Posted February 19, 2018 Brees +6 Jordan +5 Armstead +4 Thomas +3 Rankins +2 Unger +1 David +6 Evans +5 McCoy +4 Dotson +3 Alexander +2 Wintson +1 Kuechly +6 Newton +5 Short +4 Olsen +3 Davis +2 Peppers +1 Ryan +6 Julio Jones +5 Deion Jones +4 Matthews +3 Trufant +2 Jarrett +1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SteVo+ 3,702 Posted February 19, 2018 Current results through Sean. This might be the most interesting division so far...lots of tight races, including two ties that must be broken. Drew Brees 42 Cameron Jordan 27 Marshon Lattimore 21 Michael Thomas 19 Terron Armstead 14 ----- Alvin Kamara 12 Ryan Ramczyk 3 Larry Warford 3 Sheldon Rankins 2 Mark Ingram 2 Marcus Williams 1 Max Unger 1 Luke Kuechly 42 Cam Newton 28 Kawann Short 24 Greg Olsen 18 Andrew Norwell 16 ----- Thomas Davis 7 Shaq Thompson 3 Daryl Williams 2 Julius Peppers 2 Mario Addison 2 Trai Turner 2 Star Lotulelei 1 Julio Jones 38 Matt Ryan 26 Alex Mack 17 Deion Jones 16 t-Keanu Neal 12 t-Desmond Trufant 12 ----- Devonta Freeman 10 Dontari Poe 5 Matt Bryant 5 Jake Matthews 3 Grady Jarrett 1 Gerald McCoy 31 Lavonte David 28 Mike Evans 28 Robert Ayers 11 t-Demar Dotson 9 t-Kwon Alexander 9 ----- Brent Grimes 3 Doug Martin 3 Jameis Winston 2 Chris Baker 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BJORN 679 Posted February 20, 2018 +6 Gerald McCoy +5 Lavonte David +4 Mike Evans +3 Kwon Alexander +2 Demar Dotson +1 Brent Grimes +6 Julio Jones +5 Desmond Trufant +4 Deion Jones +3 Alex Mack +2 Matt Ryan +1 Keanu Neal +6 Drew Brees +5 Marshon Lattimore +4 Cameron Jordan +3 Terron Armstead +2 Larry Warford +1 Alvin Kamara +6 Luke Keuchly +5 Cam Newton +4 Thomas Davis Sr +3 Kawann Short +2 Julius Peppers +1 Greg Olsen Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SteVo+ 3,702 Posted February 23, 2018 The Divisional Round is nearing an end! You've got the rest of today (Friday) to vote before this closes. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SteVo+ 3,702 Posted February 24, 2018 Voting is closed! Final results: Drew Brees 48 Cameron Jordan 31 Marshon Lattimore 26 Michael Thomas 19 Terron Armstead 17 ----- Alvin Kamara 13 Larry Warford 5 Ryan Ramczyk 3 Sheldon Rankins 2 Mark Ingram 2 Marcus Williams 1 Max Unger 1 Luke Kuechly 48 Cam Newton 33 Kawann Short 27 Greg Olsen 19 Andrew Norwell 16 ----- Thomas Davis 11 Julius Peppers 4 Shaq Thompson 3 Daryl Williams 2 Mario Addison 2 Trai Turner 2 Star Lotulelei 1 Julio Jones 44 Matt Ryan 28 Alex Mack 20 Deion Jones 20 Desmond Trufant 17 ----- Keanu Neal 13 Devonta Freeman 10 Dontari Poe 5 Matt Bryant 5 Jake Matthews 3 Grady Jarrett 1 Gerald McCoy 37 Lavonte David 33 Mike Evans 32 Demar Dotson 14 Kwon Alexander 12 ----- Robert Ayers 11 Brent Grimes 4 Doug Martin 3 Jameis Winston 2 Chris Baker 2 All top-5 players advance to the Elimination Round. All other players receiving votes advance to the Wild Card Round. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
