KempBolt 498 Posted June 11, 2013 I think this is a good mechanism for gauging fan opinions on players not from their own teams. Pick a scheme on defense and specify. Feel free to have players fit in at positions other than what they're playing at this moment. I'm going with a one gap 3-4 for my defense. Quarterback, Aaron Rodgers, Green Bay: Even with the young talent entering the league, he's still the gold standard in my opinion. Arm talent, mobility, acumen, track record- it all speaks for itself. Running Back, Adrian Peterson, Minnesota: This will be a boring position, but how can anyone go a different direction? Running Back 2, C.J. Spiller, Buffalo: In lieu of a fullback, I'm going with a change of pace RB. Spiller's elusiveness is unparalleled and he's an amazing receiver out of the backfield. Tight End, Rob Gronkowski, New England: I think there are some warranted concerns about his back long term, but as for now no one can touch him as a dual threat blocker/receiver. Wide Receiver 1, Calvin Johnson, Detroit: The league's best true "X" receiver. Another boring selection to be sure. Wide Receiver 2, Percy Harvin, Seattle: The perfect compliment to Calvin Johnson. Having these two, plus Gronk on one team would force defenses to guard all levels of the field equally. Left Tackle, Duane Brown, Houston: Brown is the only player on my line from a primarily zone blocking scheme, but I see no reason why he couldn't play in any system. Well rounded and consistent- it's hard to find a better option. Left Guard, Marshall Yanda, Baltimore: Yanda's feet are about as good as it gets among guards in the NFL. Rare pass pro for the position, and reliable in the running game. Useful as he can pull and trap with the best of them. Center, Mike Pouncey, Miami: Mike has outplayed his brother in recent seasons in my opinion. For me, he narrowly beats out Mangold who had something of a down season (by his standards). Right Guard, Carl Nicks, Tampa Bay: After missing most of last season, Nicks is something of a forgotten man. But if he returns to pre-2012 form this year, he's still the best guard in the league. Right Tackle, Joe Staley, San Francisco: There are better pass protectors in the league, but few can touch Staley as a run blocker. His ability to get push in the ground game makes him a fit to switch sides on my dream team. Right Defensive End, J.J. Watt, Houston: It just doesn't get any more dominant than this. Nose Tackle, Geno Atkins, Cincinnati: This is a weird pick, but I think Atkins could dominate at NT in a Wade Phillips style 1 gap 3-4 (the way Ratliff thrived at one time). Left Defensive End, Calais Campbell, Arizona: I can see the argument for Justin Smith here, but I think Campbell is still ascending, while Smith is on the downhill slope. Right Outside Linebacker, Von Miller, Denver: Miller's ability to rush the passer from the edge is unparralleled, and he isn't a one trick pony either. Right Inside Linebacker, Patrick Willis, San Francisco: Excels in all facets with no true weaknesses in his game. Left Inside Linebacker, Brian Cushing, Houston: I was tempted to just go with Bowman here, but Cushing is a do-everything stud and his impact was revealed by the Texans' defensive issues while he was injured. Left Outside Lineback, Clay Matthews, Green Bay: I love players who thrive in all aspects of their position. Matthews can rush the pass rusher the best of them, but he's also a capable run defender and solid in coverage. Cornerback 1, Richard Sherman, Seattle: As much as he annoys me, I can't think of anyone who is as good in both zone and man coverage. Cornerback 2, Darrelle Revis, Tampa Bay: The only reason I've bumped him to #2 is the lost season. He may well still be the best once he returns to action. Free Safety, Jarius Byrd, Buffalo: For my money, Byrd is the best pure cover safety in the NFL. Strong Safety, Eric Weddle, San Diego: Weddle's known for his coverage, but he's also one of the best in the league at coming down into the box and stopping the run or blitzing the QB. Recap... AFCW: 2 AFCS: 3 AFE: 4 AFCN: 2 NFCW: 5 NFCS: 2 NFCE: 0 NFCN: 4 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
AllYouNeedIsLovie 377 Posted June 11, 2013 QB: Aaron Rodgers RB1: Adrian Peterson RB2: Jamaal Charles WR1: Calvin Johnson WR2: AJ Green TE: Rob Gronkowski LT: Duane Brown LG: Jahari Evans C: Max Unger RG: Carl Nicks RT: Joe Staley 3/4 D LDE: JJ Watt NT: Haloti Ngata RDE: Justin Smith ROLB: Von Miller RILB: Patrick Willis LILB: Daryl Washington LOLB: Aldon Smith CB1: Darrelle Revis CB2: Richard Sherman FS: Earl Thomas SS: Eric Weddle 4/3 D DE: Cameron Wake DT: Gerald McCoy DT: Geno Atkins DE: Jared Allen ROLB: Von Miller MLB: Patrick Willis LOLB: Lance Briggs CB1: Darrelle Revis CB2: Richard Sherman FS: Earl Thomas SS: Eric Weddle If I had to pick a defense, I'd go with the 3-4 one. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Dutch 874 Posted June 11, 2013 (edited) QB: Aaron Rodgers, - The best QB in the game. He can make every throw that all the other elite QBs can make but he's also very mobile. He throws the most accurate spiral ball on the run. It's a thing of beauty. RB: Adrian Peterson - We are witnessing an all time great in the making. http://www.thegridironpalace.com/forums/index.php?/topic/65282-adrian-peterson-a-legend-is-born/ RB 2: LeSean McCoy - Amazing running talent in this league and one of the best receiving threats at his position. He's a miss match nightmare. TE: Vernon Davis - Gronk is an amazing talent but is too hurt for my liking. Davis is a tremendous talent and having that type of speed and athleticism at this position on an all star team would be devastating for defenses to defend. WR: Calvin Johnson - Can't argue with his production. He imposes defenses with his god gifted abilities athleticism with speed, jumping ability and his big body. WR 2: Larry Fitzgerald - My favorite WR in the league. Larry Fitzgerald is the true epitome of the WR position. He's the most complete receiver in the league. He's a route technician and can run all the routes, he has the best hands in the league (hands down), insane acrobatic jumping ability (people tend to forget that with the emergence of Megatron), and can block well. He may not have have great straight line speed but he can beat you deep. His speed is deceptive speed on the field. LT: Duane Brown - Pre injury, I'd take Jason Peters who was the best LT in football. The jury is still out if he can still play at that elite level. LG: Evan Mathis - Very underrated and played at a high level last year when no one else on the Eagles line did. C: Nick Mangold RG: Jahri Evans RT: Sebastian Vollmer :Patriots: Defense 4-3 LE: Cameron Wake - An underrated beast DT: Geno Atkins - best DT in football DT: Brandon Membane RE: Von Miller LOLB: Luke Kuechly - I know I'm stretching here with him being a rookie but I simply love this kid and believe his potential through the roof. So this is a potential pick but logically unbiased side told me to go with Navarro Bowman. MLB: Patrick Willis - Best MLB in the game. ROLB: Clay Matthews CB 1: Darrelle Revis - Still the best cornerback in football until proven other wise. I said the same thing about A.P last year. CB 2: Richard Sherman FS: Jarius Byrd - Extremely underrated and usually isn't mentioned in discussions of top safeties in the league. SS: Eric Weddle - Going to have to agree with Kemp here. Weddle is the best and most efficient tackling safety in the league and I believe he would transition to SS with ease. Special Teams: Kickers and Punters are people to you know. Kicker: Blair Walsh - Outstanding rookie year. He made 10/10 field goals over 50 yards; amazing. Punter: Andy Lee Kick Returner: Percy Harvin Punt Returner: DeSean Jackson Division Break Down AFCN-1 AFCS-1 AFCE-4 AFCW-2 NFCN-5 NFCS-3 NFCE-3 NFCW-7 Edited June 11, 2013 by dutchff7 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
12th Man 0 Posted June 12, 2013 (edited) I couldn't narrow it down in spots, so I just decided to include my 45 man game day roster. I have a few guys playing out of position, but it would not worry me in the slightest. I have depth, for situational rotations. My defense would be the 3-4, with a fully capable Nickle Package. Also, in reality I would drop a running back or two, and pick up another safety, but like I said, I could not choose between the bottom 2-3. I also I realize I am very heavy on Seattle, and while Unger(run blocking up middle) and Wagner(3rd on depth chart)may well be stretches, my homerism was not intentional. QB: Aaron Rodgers Packers Drew Brees Saints Russal Wilson Seahawks RB: Adrian Petterson Vikings Marshawn Lynch Seahawks CJ Spiller Bills Trent Richardson Browns MJD Jags WR: Calvin Johnson Lions Andre Johnson Texans Larry Fitzgerald Cardinals Percy Harvin Seahawks Steve Smith Panthers TE: Vernon Davis 49ers Gronk Patriots OC: Max Unger Seahawks Chris Myers Texans OG: Mike Iupati 49ers Marshal Yanda Ravens OT: Russell Okung Seahawks Duane Brown Texans Ryan Clady Broncos Joe Staley 49ers DT: Geno Atkins Beangals Vince Wolfork Patriots Gerald McCoy Bucs Haloti Ngata Ravens DE: JJ Watt Texans Calais Campbell Cardinals Ziggy Ansah Lions Jared Allen Vikings ILB: Patrick Willis 49ers Brian Cushing Texans Bobby Wagner Seahawks OLB: Vonn Miller Broncos Aldon Smith 49ers Clay Mathews Packers CB: Darrelle Revis Bucs Richard Sherman Seahawks Brandon Browner Seahawks Charles Tillman Bears SS: Eric Weddle Chargers FS: Earl Thomas Seahawks K: Janokoski Raiders P: Shane Lechler Raiders KR: Percy Harvin PR: MJD Edited June 12, 2013 by 12th Man Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Zack_of_Steel+ 3,014 Posted June 12, 2013 Leave it to a Seahawks fan to have half of his dream roster full of Seahawks. 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Dutch 874 Posted June 12, 2013 PR: MJD Definitely Seahawk heavy lol. But that's fine because it's your own Dream Team. But the only thing that I'm confused about is MJD at returning punts? Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
12th Man 0 Posted June 12, 2013 Definitely Seahawk heavy lol. But that's fine because it's your own Dream Team. But the only thing that I'm confused about is MJD at returning punts? If I kept him on the roster it would be the only way he'd get on the field, really didn't think about that one, just knew I'd have Harvin as KR. In reality, I'm not sure if it's worth the risk to have Harvin out there returning kicks for the Hawks every Sunday. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Dutch 874 Posted June 12, 2013 (edited) Dream Team 2.0 QB: Drew Brees You can't argue with Drew Brees numbers in the last 4-5 years. He trumps all QBs with his statistical production. He airs it out. RB: Jamaal Charles Probably doesn't get as much recognition as he deserves. The man just had the lowest YPC average of his career; 5.3 yards. He makes the most of his carries and has throughout his career. He's a gasher. RB 2: Marshawn Lynch Beast mode. WR: A.J Green My second favorite WR in the league. This kid is a special talent and already is a top 5 WR. He plays the game so smooth and makes everything look easy. He game is very fluid. WR 2: Brandon Marshall I opted to go with Dez Bryant but I want to have receivers with different skill sets. Brandon Marshall (underrated) is a beast and is very dangerous when he gets the ball in his hands. So is Dez but Brandon Marshall is a great possession receiver that will eat you up between the numbers and moves the chains very well. TE: Jimmy Graham LT: Ryan Clady LG: Marshall Yonda C: Max Unger RG: Carl Nicks RT: Joe Staley Defense 3-4 RDE: J.J Watt NT: Haloti Ngata LDE: Justin Smith LOLB: Aldon Smith LILB: Daryl Washington RILB: Navarro Bowman ROLB: Demarcus Ware CB 1: Patrick Peterson I really like this kid. He is easily the most athletically gifted CB at his position. Elite speed, recovery speed / acceleration, outstanding ball skills, agility, soft hand but just needs to clean up his technique a bit. Once he does that, I think he can become the best corner in football. CB: Brandon Flowers FS : Earl Thomas SS: Reshad Jones Special Teams Kicker: Sebastian Janikowski Punter: Shane Lechler Kick Returner: Jacoby Jones Punt Returner: Patrick Peterson Edited June 12, 2013 by dutchff7 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bay 2,003 Posted June 12, 2013 I liked Razor's (?) idea where you could only pick one player per team. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
KempBolt 498 Posted June 12, 2013 I liked Razor's (?) idea where you could only pick one player per team. That's a cool idea. QB: Aaron Rodgers, Packers RB: Adrian Peterson, Vikings RB2: Jamaal Charles, Chiefs TE: Rob Gronkowski, Patriots WR1: Calvin Johnson, Lions WR2: Brandon Marshall, Bears LT: D'Brickashaw Ferguson, Jets LG: Marshal Yanda, Ravens C: Alex Mack, Browns RG: Carl Nicks, Buccaneers RT: Eugene Monroe, Jaguars RDE: J.J. Watt, Texans NT: Geno Atkins, Bengals LDE: Calais Campbell, Cardinals ROLB: Von Miller, Broncos RILB: Patrick Willis, 49ers LILB: Sean Lee, Cowboys LOLB: Cameron Wake, Dolphins CB1: Richard Sherman, Seahawks CB2: Cortland Finnegan, Rams FS: Jarius Byrd, Bills SS: Eric Weddle, Chargers Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
housemd 338 Posted June 12, 2013 QB: Aaron Rodgers RB1: Adrian Peterson RB2: Jamaal Charles WR1: Calvin Johnson WR2: Larry Fitzgerald TE: Rob Gronkowski :Patriots: LT: Duane Brown LG: Marshall Yanda C: Mike Pouncey RG: Carl Nicks RT: Joe Staley LDE: JJ Watt NT: Haloti Ngata (a 3-4 DE but I have to put him here) RDE: Justin Smith LOLB: Clay Matthews LILB: Daryl Washington RILB: Patrick Willis ROLB: Von Miller CB1: Richard Sherman CB2: Darrelle Revis FS: Jairus Byrd SS: Eric Weddle K: Blair Walsh P: Andy Lee Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bucman 891 Posted June 12, 2013 QB: Aaron Rodgers RB1: Adrian Peterson RB2: Jamaal Charles WR1: Calvin Johnson WR2: AJ Green TE: Rob Gronkowski LT: Joe Thomas LG: Mike Iupati C: Nick Mangold RG: Marshal Yanda RT: Sebastian Vollmer 4/3 D LDE: Cameron Wake UT: Geno Atkins NT: Nick Fairley RDE: Jared Allen Will: Lavonte David Mike: Patrick Willis Sam: Von Miller CB1: Darrelle Revis CB2: Richard Sherman FS: Dashon Goldson SS: Eric Weddle Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
CampinWithaMissingPerson 2,025 Posted June 12, 2013 If I kept him on the roster it would be the only way he'd get on the field, really didn't think about that one, just knew I'd have Harvin as KR. In reality, I'm not sure if it's worth the risk to have Harvin out there returning kicks for the Hawks every Sunday. That's just it though, MJD sucks at returning punts. He was good in college at it, but in the NFL he was never able to field balls cleanly on a consistent basis. That's why he's only got a total of 15 punt returns in his whole career. He's only been asked to do it when guys got hurt, etc. He's a much better KR. Actually, Harvin would be the better PR choice and MJD the better KR. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
FartWaffles 1,857 Posted June 17, 2013 I'll create a my dream modern day Run and Shoot offense. X.........LT.LG.C.RG.RT...........Z ......W................................Y ......................QB...RB QB: Ben Roethlisberger -His uncanny ability to extend plays is perfect for the Run and Shoot considering that this offense is constantly blitzed against. There's no other quarterback in the league better suited for this offense IMO. X: Mike Wallace Z: Steve Smith -Both Wallace and Smith can take the top off of a defense with their speed, and both are smart at quickly finding the holes in defensive coverages. I also like giving Roethlisberger a familiar target with Wallace. W: Wes Welker Y: Percy Harvin -Arguably the two best inside slot receivers in the business today. Having both Harvin and Welker on the field would absolutely give defenses fits! One on ones with a linebacker will make for easy pickens. RB: Arian Foster -As you will see below I will be incorporating a zone-blocking scheme with the offensive linemen, and there's no better ZBS back in the NFL today than Foster and his amazing vision to see the cutback lanes. He also has great hands as a receiver and can bail Roethlisberger out with screen plays. OFFENSIVE LINE (Zone-blocking scheme) LT: Duane Brown LG: Wade Smith C: Chris Myers RG: Max Unger RT: Russell Okung Great group of o-linemen here perfect for the scheme, and cut blocking could give Roethlisberger more time to stand in the pocket and dissect defenses. Welp there you have it. This is my dream offense with current NFL players. 1 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
