SteVo+ 3,702 Posted February 12, 2018 Our journey toward naming the best player in football begins with our Divisional Round, where we list the best players on each team. Remember you're identifying the best players in the NFL right now, so performance in the 2017 season should be a principal factor but not the only factor. Here's how it works: For each team, nominate who you think are the six best players on their roster, assigning +6 points to the best player, +5 points to the second-best player, and so on. Assemble a top 6 for all four teams in the AFC West. Feel free to discuss/debate the rankings of others; that's part of the fun of this process. NOTE: We are operating under rosters effective the end of the regular season, so Alex Smith still counts as a Chief. Here are my picks: +6 Kareem Hunt +5 Travis Kelce +4 Chris Jones +3 Justin Houston +2 Eric Berry +1 Alex Smith +6 Joey Bosa +5 Philip Rivers +4 Melvin Ingram +3 Casey Hayward +2 Keenan Allen +1 Melvin Gordon +6 Khalil Mack +5 Rodney Hudson +4 Kelechi Osemele +3 Donald Penn +2 Marshawn Lynch +1 Karl Joseph +6 Von Miller +5 Chris Harris +4 Aqib Talib +3 Demaryius Thomas +2 C.J. Anderson +1 Matt Paradis A lot of talent in this division...for every team I made an initial list of seven or more players that I had to trim down. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
WeaponX20 26 Posted February 12, 2018 Cheifs +6 Eric Berry +5 Justin Houston +4 Travis Kelce +3 Kareem Hunt +2 Chris Jones +1 Marcus Peters Broncos +6 Von Miller +5 Chris Harris Jr +4 Aqib Talib +3 Demaryius Thomas +2 Emmanuel Sanders +1 Cj Anderson Chargers +6 Joey Bosa +5 Melvin Ingram +4 Phillip Rivers +3Casey Heyward +2 Melvin Gordon +1 Kennan Allen Raiders +6 Khali Mack +5 Kelchei Osmele +4 Donald Penn +3 Rodney Hudson +2 Derrick Carr +1 Amari Cooper Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Packers Dynasty 2010 116 Posted February 13, 2018 (edited) +6 Travis Kelce +5 Eric Berry +4 Justin Houston +3 Marcus Peters +2 Kareem Hunt +1 Alex Smith +6 Casey Hayward, best corner in the league +5 Melvin Ingram +4 Joey Bosa +3 Keenan Allen +2 Phillip Rivers +1 Melvin Gordon +6 Von Miller +5 Aqib Talib +4 Chris Harris Jr +3 Demaryius Thomas +2 Brandon Marshall +1 Derek Wolfe +6 Kahil Mack +5 Rodney Hudson +4 Kelechi Osemele +3 Derek Carr +2 Donald Penn +1 Bruce Irvin Edited February 13, 2018 by Packers Dynasty 2010 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
RazorStar 4,025 Posted February 13, 2018 +6 Joey Bosa +5 Philip Rivers +4 Keenan Allen +3 Melvin Ingram +2 Casey Heyward +1 Brandon Mebane +6 Von Miller +5 Chris Harris +4 Derek Wolfe +3 Aqib Talib +2 Bradley Roby +1 Matt Paradis +6 Marcus Peters +5 Eric Berry +4 Travis Kelce +3 Alex Smith +2 Justin Houston +1 Kareem Hunt +6 Khalil Mack +5 Derek Carr +4 Rodney Hudson +3 Kelechi Osemele +2 NaVorro Bowman +1 Amari Cooper Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Thanatos 2,847 Posted February 13, 2018 +6 Joey Bosa +5 Keenan Allen +4 Casey Heyward +3 Melvin Ingram +2 Phillip Rivers +1 Melvin Gordon +6 Eric Berry +5 Travis Kelce +4 Justin Houston +3 Kareem Hunt +2 Marcus Peters +1 Alex Smith +6 Khalil Mack +5 Kelechi Osemele +4 Donald Penn +3 Derek Carr +2 Michael Crabtree +1 Amari Cooper +6 Von Miller +5 Aqib Talib +4 Chris Harris +3 Derek Wolfe +2 Brandon Marshall +1 Matt Paradis Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BJORN 679 Posted February 13, 2018 +6 Joey Bosa +5 Keenan Allen +4 Casey Hayward +3 Melvin Ingram +2 Philip Rivers +1 Desmond King +6 Khalil Mack +5 Reggie Nelson +4 Donald Penn +3 Kelechi Osemele +2 Bruce Irvin +1 Derek Carr +6 Eric Berry +5 Travis Kelce +4 Justin Houston +3 Kareem Hunt +2 Alex Smith +1 Marcus Peters +6 Von Miller +5 Chris Harris Jr +4 Brandon Marshall +3 Demaryius Thomas +2 Derek Wolfe +1 Matt Paradis Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BC 331 Posted February 14, 2018 Pondering my rankings before I post them. Man the Chiefs are hard. For me, Travis Kelce, Eric Berry, Marcus Peters, and Kareem Hunt are all at the same level of awesomeness. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BC 331 Posted February 14, 2018 +6 Marcus Peters +5 Travis Kelce +4 Eric Berry +3 Kareem Hunt +2 Justin Houston +1 Tyreek Hill +6 Von Miller +5 Aqib Talib +4 Chris Harris Jr +3 Derek Wolfe +2 Demaryius Thomas +1 Matt Paradis +6 Khalil Mack +5 Kelechi Osemele +4 Reggie Nelson +3 Donald Penn +2 Derek Carr +1 Bruce Irvin +6 Joey Bosa +5 Casey Hayward +4 Keenan Allen +3 Melvin Ingram +2 Melvin Gordon +1 Philip Rivers Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
seanbrock 1,684 Posted February 15, 2018 (edited) Berry +6 Houston +5 Kelce +4 Hunt +3 Peters +2 Schwartz +1 Bosa +6 Rivers +5 Heyward +4 Allen +3 Ingram +2 Gordon +1 Mack +6 Carr +5 Osemele +4 Penn +3 Crabtree +2 Hudson +1 Miller +6 Harris Jr. +5 Marshall + 4 Talib +3 Paradis +2 Wolfe +1 Was gonna change my pick to Alex Smith when I realized he would be counted as a Chief but I figured Schwartz deserves at least 1 point. Edited February 15, 2018 by seanbrock Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Cherry 1,302 Posted February 15, 2018 +6 Eric Berry +5 Marcus Peters +4 Tyreek Hill +3 Travis Kelce +2 Justin Houston +1 Kareem Hunt +6 Von Miller +5 Chris Harris +4 Aqib Talib +3 Brandon Marshall +2 Emmanuel Sanders +1 Derek Wolfe +6 Khalil Mack +5 Kelechi Osemele +4 Donald Penn +3 Derek Carr +2 Michael Crabtree +1 Reggie Nelson +6 Joey Bosa +5 Philip Rivers +4 Casey Heyward +3 Melvin Ingram +2 Keenan Allen +1 Melvin Gordon Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
BC 331 Posted February 16, 2018 Tyreek Hill over Kelce !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SteVo+ 3,702 Posted February 16, 2018 Keep those ballots rolling in, folks. These are the current (not final) results, through Cherry. We've got well defined top 5's for two teams, one that's super close, and two edge defenders with perfect scores so far. Eric Berry 46 Travis Kelce 41 Justin Houston 31 Marcus Peters 26 Kareem Hunt 25 ----- Alex Smith 8 Chris Jones 6 Tyreek Hill 5 Mitchell Schwartz 1 Joey Bosa 52 Casey Hayward 35 Philip Rivers 31 Melvin Ingram 31 Keenan Allen 26 ----- Melvin Gordon 9 Brandon Mebane 1 Desmond King 1 Khalil Mack 54 Kelechi Osemele 38 Donald Penn 27 Derek Carr 24 Rodney Hudson 18 ----- Reggie Nelson 11 Michael Crabtree 6 Bruce Irvin 4 Amari Cooper 3 NaVorro Bowman 2 Marshawn Lynch 2 Karl Joseph 1 Von Miller 54 Chris Harris 42 Aqib Talib 33 Brandon Marshall 15 Derek Wolfe 15 ----- Demaryius Thomas 14 Matt Paradis 7 Emmanuel Sanders 4 C.J. Anderson 3 Bradley Roby 2 Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SteVo+ 3,702 Posted February 19, 2018 Last chance to get in on the action is TODAY... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SteVo+ 3,702 Posted February 20, 2018 Voting is closed. Final results: Eric Berry 46 Travis Kelce 41 Justin Houston 31 Marcus Peters 26 Kareem Hunt 25 ----- Alex Smith 8 Chris Jones 6 Tyreek Hill 5 Mitchell Schwartz 1 Joey Bosa 52 Casey Hayward 35 Philip Rivers 31 Melvin Ingram 31 Keenan Allen 26 ----- Melvin Gordon 9 Brandon Mebane 1 Desmond King 1 Khalil Mack 54 Kelechi Osemele 38 Donald Penn 27 Derek Carr 24 Rodney Hudson 18 ----- Reggie Nelson 11 Michael Crabtree 6 Bruce Irvin 4 Amari Cooper 3 NaVorro Bowman 2 Marshawn Lynch 2 Karl Joseph 1 Von Miller 54 Chris Harris 42 Aqib Talib 33 Brandon Marshall 15 Derek Wolfe 15 ----- Demaryius Thomas 14 Matt Paradis 7 Emmanuel Sanders 4 C.J. Anderson 3 Bradley Roby 2 All top-5 players advance to the Elimination Round. All other players receiving votes advance to the Wild Card Round. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites