BPitNFL Elimination Group 5: Trench warriors

[SteVo+ 3,702]

Elimination Round -- Group 5

 

Voters: rank the top 6 players from the following:

 

ED Calais Campbell

ED J.J. Watt

ED Justin Houston

OT Donald Penn

OT Jason Peters

OG Brandon Scherff

DI Linval Joseph

WR Davante Adams

CB Malcolm Butler

DI Brandon Williams

[RazorStar 4,025]

+6 Calais Campbell

+5 Malcolm Butler

+4 Linval Joseph

+3 Brandon Williams

+2 Brandon Scherff

+1 Justin Houston

---

Jason Peters (Close to sneaking onto the list, his injury this year was the deciding factor for me. He might have made it on a less stacked list.)

Donald Penn (I've always thought Penn was overated. He's alright, but not top 100 worthy for me.)

Davante Adams (A product of Aaron Rodgers, I'd be remiss to include him)

J.J. Watt (Dude has played 8 games and has 1.5 sacks in his last two years. When he was on he was the GOAT, now he's nothing special)

[Packers Dynasty 2010 116]

+6 Calais Campbell

+5 Justin Houston

+4 Davante Adams

+3 Linval Joseph

+2 Brandon Scherff

+1 Malcolm Butler

Edited March 8, 2018 by Packers Dynasty 2010

[BJORN 679]

Peters would be in +4 territory for me if he didn't miss most of the season. I still give him credit because he is one of my favorite offensive lineman along with Scherff. I want to see more from Brandon Williams and Davante Adams next season before they are elevated onto a list amongst these guys.

 

+6 Calais Campbell

+5 Justin Houston

+4 Brandon Scherff

+3 Linval Joseph

+2 Malcolm Butler

+1 Jason Peters

[Thanatos 2,847]

+6 Calais Campbell

+5 Linval Joseph

+4 Brandon Scherff

+3 Jason Peters

+2 Donald Penn

+1 Malcolm Butler

Edited March 8, 2018 by Thanatos

[seanbrock 1,684]

Campbell +6

Houston +5

Joseph +4

Williams +3

Peters +2

Watt +1

[OSUViking 505]

+6 Calais Campbell

 

+5 Justin Houston

+4 Linval Joseph

+3 Brandon Scherff

+2 Jason Peters

+1 Davante Adams

 

I went with Adams over Butler because I see way more of Adams than I do Butler.

[oochymp 2,393]

+6 Calais Campbell

+5 Jason Peters

+4 Justin Houston

+3 Donald Penn

+2 J.J. Watt

+1 Brandon Scherff

Edited March 9, 2018 by oochymp

[SteVo+ 3,702]

+6 Calais Campbell

+5 Jason Peters

+4 Justin Houston

+3 J.J. Watt

+2 Brandon Scherff

+1 Linval Joseph

 

I really struggled with where to put Watt, but I felt there was a tangible gap between the top 3 and everyone else, so I put Watt in between them. Also, Jason Peters is still elite. Don't @ me.

[WeaponX20 26]

+6 JJ Watt

+5 Justin Houston

+4 Calais Campbell

+3 Jason Peters

+2 Donald Penn

+1 Brandon Scherff

[SteVo+ 3,702]

Results current through Weapon. All ten players receiving votes, with a close battle overall though Campbell is running away with first place.

 

Calais Campbell 52

Justin Houston 34

Linval Joseph 24

Jason Peters 21

Brandon Scherff 19

J.J. Watt 12

-----

Malcolm Butler 9

Donald Penn 7

Brandon Williams 6

Davante Adams 5

[SteVo+ 3,702]

Voting is closed! Final results in the above post.