BPitNFL Elimination Group 6: Positional medley

[SteVo+ 3,702]

Elimination Round -- Group 6

 

Voters, rank the top 6 players from the following:

 

OT Jack Conklin

ED Jabaal Sheard

QB Philip Rivers

CB Aqib Talib

RB Ezekiel Elliott

DI Damon Harrison

WR Golden Tate

LB Akiem Hicks

S Tony Jefferson

LB Preston Brown

[RazorStar 4,025]

+6 Damon Harrison

+5 Tony Jefferson

+4 Philip Rivers

+3 Jack Conklin

+2 Aqib Talib

+1 Akiem Hicks

---

Ezekiel Elliott (It was tough deciding between him, Hicks, Conklin and Talib to take my last three slots. I figured Zeke would get plenty of votes anyway, so best to represent the more underated Hicks and Conklin, and go homer on Talib a bit.)

Preston Brown (He's a very good linebacker, just not the kind of dynamic player these other guys are.)

Golden Tate (Solid wide receiver, but he's not in your elite category.)

Jabaal Sheard (Basically just on the list because the Colts don't have enough good players.)

[Packers Dynasty 2010 116]

+6 Phillip Rivers

+5 Damon Harrison

+4 Aqib Talib

+3 Jack Conklin

+2 Ezekiel Elliot

+1 Tony Jefferson

[BJORN 679]

Uh this is a hard one.....

 

+6 Damon Harrison

+5 Phil Rivers

+4 Jack Conklin

+3 Zeke Elliott

+2 Tony Jefferson

+1 Akiem Hicks

[Thanatos 2,847]

+6 Damon Harrison

+5 Phillip Rivers

+4 Jack Conklin

+3 Aqib Talib

+2 Ezekiel Elliot

+1 Akiem Hicks

[seanbrock 1,684]

Elliot +6 (what non QB has as much impact on their team? I hate Dallas but man...)

Rivers +5

Harrison +4

Talib +3

Conklin +2

Hicks +1

Edited March 8, 2018 by seanbrock

[SteVo+ 3,702]

+6 Damon Harrison

+5 Philip Rivers

+4 Jabaal Sheard

+3 Jack Conklin

+2 Ezekiel Elliott

+1 Aqib Talib

 

Man, this group has some depth. I gave all ten players a hard look for the top 6.

 

I'm glad Snacks is getting some love after being voted the Giants' 4th-best player. More people would talk about Sheard if he weren't stuck on the Colts. Zeke is overrated but I couldn't keep him off this list. It was very painful to cut Golden Tate; every time I watch him play he does something that amazes me.

[seanbrock 1,684]

Meh, I think Sheard is overrated. He has 41.5 sacks in 7 season with no double digits sack seasons.

[WeaponX20 26]

+6 Aqib Talib

+5 Phillip Rivers

+4 Damon Harrison

+3 Jack Conklin

+2 Tony Jefferson

+1 Ezekiel Elliot

[SteVo+ 3,702]

Results current through Weapon. Unlike most other groups, there's a close race at the top and a defined top 6 overall.

 

Damon Harrison 37

Philip Rivers 35

Jack Conklin 22

Aqib Talib 19

Ezekiel Elliott 16

Tony Jefferson 10

-----

Akiem Hicks 4

Jabaal Sheard 4

Edited March 12, 2018 by SteVo

[RazorStar 4,025]

you may want to check your totals again Steven.

[SteVo+ 3,702]

[oochymp 2,393]

+6 Damon Harrison

+5 Golden Tate

+4 Philip Rivers

+3 Jabaal Sheard

+2 Aqib Talib

+1 Ezekiel Elliott

 

this feels like a really weak group, is that just me?

Edited March 13, 2018 by oochymp

[OSUViking 505]

+6 Damon Harrison

+5 Tony Jefferson

+4 Philip Rivers

+3 Jack Conklin

+2 Aqib Talib

+1 Akiem Hicks

[SteVo+ 3,702]

Voting is closed. Final results:

 

Damon Harrison 49

Philip Rivers 43

Jack Conklin 25

Aqib Talib 23

Ezekiel Elliott 17

Tony Jefferson 15

-----

Jabaal Sheard 7

Golden Tate 5

Akiem Hicks 5