PFF ranks the top 101 players from the 2010 season

[BLUE 1,026]

101-81

 

80-61

 

60-41

 

40-21

 

20-1

Edited May 10, 2011 by BLUE

[Shotgun 442]

LOL@ Matt Ryan #8. People need to get off this dudes nuts. He ain't that damn good.

 

And Tom Brady #33? Behind Brees, Ryan, Peyton, Rivers? What the fuck is this dude smoking?

Edited May 10, 2011 by Shotgun

[Piggly Wiggly 960]

Holy mother of fuck, these rankings are terrible.

 

I think this guy was trying way too hard to be cool and trendy by putting a handful of the less recognized names higher than they should be. Also the fact that he's biased towards some players and has beef against others made this list a steaming hot pile of horse shit.

[Zack_of_Steel+ 3,014]

Roethlisberger wasn't even in the top 101. Lmao.

[RazorStar 4,025]

Using our top 128, I'm gonna try to formulate our TGP top 100. Using XStats may make it a bit messy, and some teams will prolly get jipped with representatives, but it's worth a short.

 

Here are our top 16, sort of.

 

1. Troy Polamalu

2. Aaron Rodgers

3. Tom Brady

4. Nnamdi Asomugha

5. DeMarcus ware

6. Darrelle Revis

7. Andre Johnson

8. Philip Rivers

9. Patrick Willis

10. Drew Brees

11. Joe Thomas

12. Haloti Ngata

13. Larry Fitzgerald

14. Trent Cole

15. Calvin Johnson

16. Justin Smith

[BucD+ 648]

WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW!!

 

lmao.

 

Joke website is a joke.

[AllYouNeedIsLovie 377]

LMAO! PFF sucks. That list is sooooo bad. I was going to stop reading once I saw Percy Harvin make the list, but I decided to read the rest for laughs.

[ATL_Predator+ 1,196]

lmfao Trent Cole? List fails hard...

[BLUE 1,026]

I mean, I like PFF for the stats and studies they do....but the gradings and rankings make my brain hurt sometimes....it's one thing to think outside of the box.....it's completely another to put a large catapult in the box, hop in that bitch and fire yourself ten billion miles away from it....

Edited May 10, 2011 by BLUE

[badgers 380]

Yo dude you're missing numbers.

 

It goes 80-61, 60-41, 40-21, 20-1

 

You have 60-21.

 

Here's 60-41, guys: http://www.profootballfocus.com/blog/2011/05/02/the-top-101-players-of-2010-no-60-%E2%80%93-no-41/

[BLUE 1,026]

Thank you, gobadgers77. Original post edited.

[DonovanMcnabb for H.O.F 2,241]

It's one thing to think outside of the box.....it's completely another to put a large catapult in the box, hop in that bitch and fire yourself ten billion miles away from it....

 

Reason why I cut my subscription with PFF, I like the stats, but some of this stuff seems like it's too much.

[RazorStar 4,025]

DMac... fuck, give me that shit.

[RazorStar 4,025]

XStats mades our list pretty retarded. This isn't factoring how far a player got in the tournament, but instead purely percentages against percentages in a recursive format. I'll be doing some tiebreakers, sorting by round eliminated to get a better list later. (Changes made to the blowout adjustments, 1/8, 1/6, 1/5, 1/4)

 

1. Troy Polamalu 50.00%

2. Tom Brady 48.39%

3. Aaron Rodgers 45.45%

4. Nnamdi Asomugha 41.06%

5. Andre Johnson 40.40%

6. DeMarcus Ware 33.45%

7. Patrick Willis 33.06%

8. Philip Rivers 29.63%

9. Darrelle Revis 28.67%

10. Joe Thomas 25.00%

11. Drew Brees 24.24%

12. Trent Cole 22.33%

13. Haloti Ngata 21.29%

14. Jamaal Charles 21.02%

15. Antonio Gates 19.40%

16. Larry Fitz 18.25%

17. James Harrison 18.18%

18. Calvin Johnson 17.32%

19. Mario Williams 17.11%

20. Peyton Manning 17.03%

 

Joe Haden 16.67%

Justin Smith 15.40%

Andre Whitworth 14.81%

Ben Roeth 14.14%

25. Justin Tuck 13.94%

Ed Reed 13.89%

Vince Wilfork 13.82%

Jon Beason 13.82%

Jason Witten 13.69%

30. Ray Lewis 13.16%

Laurinaitis 13.04%

Julius Peppers 12.88%

Champ Bailey 12.43%

Kyle Williams 12.12%

35. MJD 11.76%

John Babineaux 11.52%

Nick Mangold 11.15%

D'Brickashaw 11.06%

London Fletcher 10.95%

40. Reggie Wayne 10.77%

 

Logan Mankins 10.19%

Roddy White 10.17%

Tramon Williams 10.10%

Cameron Wake 9.70%

45. Ryan Clady 9.66%

Tony Romo 9.56%

Arian Foster 9.51%

Ndamukong Suh 9.51%

Vernon Davis 9.32%

50. Carl Nicks 9.24%

John Abraham 9.22%

Alex Mack 9.09%

BJ Raji 9.09%

Adrian Peterson 9.05%

55. Earl Thomas 8.82%

OJ Atogwe 8.80%

Jerod Mayo 8.19%

Chris Johnson 7.90%

Clay Matthews 7.76%

60. Charles Johnson 7.66%

 

Derrick Johnson 7.46%

Jake Long 7.43%

Josh Freeman 7.39%

Lofa Tatupu 7.35%

65. Aqib Talib 7.07%

Shady McCoy 7.05%

Brian Orakpo 7.04%

Brandon Flowers 6.97%

James Anderson 6.93%

70. Quintin Mikell 6.58%

Richard Seymour 6.44%

Jahri Evans 6.16%

Vontae Davis 6.04%

Hakeem Nicks 5.84%

75. Terrell Suggs 5.81%

Tamba Hali 5.74%

Chris Long 5.60%

Brandon Marshall 5.46%

Elvis Dumervil 5.39%

80. Calais Campbell 5.34%

 

Miles Austin 5.25%

Dwight Freeney 5.24%

Ray Rice 5.00%

Brian Urlacher 4.95%

85. DeMeco Ryans 4.86%

David Hawthorne 4.80%

Jordan Gross 4.07%

Steven Jackson 4.05%

LaMarr Woodley 4.04%

90. Eric Winston 4.03%

Antoine Bethea 4.01%

Ahmad Bradshaw 3.98%

Lance Briggs 3.88%

Santonio Holmes 3.88%

95. Leon Hall 3.87%

Mike Wallace 3.87%

Greg Jennings 3.85%

Brandon Carr 3.82%

Matt Forte 3.71%

100. Chad Greenway 3.68%

 

---

 

Brandon Lloyd 3.53%

Darnell Dockett 3.39%

Curtis Lofton 3.39%

LaRon Landry 3.22%

Jay Ratliff 3.19%

Dallas Clark 3.14%

Matt Ryan 3.08%

Chris Snee 2.94%

Mercedes Lewis 2.87%

Kevin Williams 2.86%

John Joseph 2.83%

Nate Clements 2.81%

Jason Jones 2.77%

Mike Williams 2.63%

David Harris 2.55%

Santana Moss 2.55%

Paul Posluszny 2.35%

Josh Sitton 2.26%

Zach Miller 2.26%

Ron Bartell 2.01%

Karlos Dansby 1.57%

Matt Schaub 1.40%

Antoine Winfield 1.38%

Ryan Kalil 1.36%

Darren McFadden 1.27%

Kamerion Wimbley 1.04%

Kenny Britt 0.85%

Brandon Mebane 0.74%

Edited May 11, 2011 by RazorStar
I messed with the blowout adjustments, this is much better IMO.

[RazorStar 4,025]

*note* A lot of those are adjusted for blowout, I should tweak my blowout adjustment formula though, previously it was just to keep the vote difference between matches where the opponent has less than 20% of the vote (rounded to nearest whole number), and make it so that player gets the lowest amount of votes.

 

Example, these matches all have 15 votes

 

Player A 15

Player B 0

 

Player C 14

Player D 1

 

Player E 13

Player F 2

 

Player G 12

Player H 3

 

these become

 

Player A 18

Player B 3

 

Player C 16

Player D 3

 

Player E 14

Player F 3

 

Player G 12

Player H 3

 

I should lower that 20% mark to 1/8 in the first round, and 1/6 in the second, then I'll get back to it.

[RANGA+ 1,210]

PFF's biggest problem with shit like this is that they try too hard to look smart in their own unique way. And it usually ends up backfiring...

[SteVo+ 3,702]

All of you who are trashing PFF should keep in mind that the guys who run those stats watch game film and analyze every single play. They don't just find the numbers out of some complex equation into which they plug endless numbers of stats. So it's not like these guys aren't credible.

[BoneKrusher+ 1,276]

PFF's biggest problem with shit like this is that they try too hard to look smart in their own unique way. And it usually ends up backfiring...

 

 

i agree but i should keep my mouth shut because they have two Chiefs in the top ten. :wink:

[DonovanMcnabb for H.O.F 2,241]

DMac... fuck, give me that shit.

lol. Im 2 weeks removed from subscription, I don't have access to anything. =/

[RazorStar 4,025]

Ok comprehensive list, sorted by how far players got in the tournament, and then by X-Stats.

 

1. Troy Polamalu

2. Aaron Rodgers

3. Tom Brady

4. Nnamdi Asomugha

5. DeMarcus ware

6. Darrelle Revis

7. Andre Johnson

8. Philip Rivers

9. Patrick Willis

10. Drew Brees

11. Joe Thomas

12. Haloti Ngata

13. Larry Fitzgerald

14. Trent Cole

15. Calvin Johnson

16. Justin Smith

17. Jamaal Charles

18. James Harrison

19. Mario Williams

20. Peyton Manning

21. Justin Tuck

22. Jon Beason

23. Jason Witten

24. James Laurinaitis

25. Julius Peppers

26. Champ Bailey

27. Kyle Williams

28. Maurice Jones-Drew

29. Nick Mangold

30. Roddy White

31. Carl Nicks

32. Adrian Peterson

 

33-64

33. Antonio Gates

34. Joe Haden

35. Ben Roethlisberger

36. Ed Reed

37. Vince Wilfork

38. Johnathan Babineaux

39. London Fletcher

40. Reggie Wayne

41. Tramon Williams

42. Cameron Wake

43. Ryan Clady

44. Tony Romo

45. Vernon Davis

46. John Abraham

47. OJ Atogwe

48. Jerod Mayo

49. Chris Johnson

50. Clay Matthews

51. Charles Johnson

52. Jake Long

53. Josh Freeman

54. Lofa Tatupu

55. Shady McCoy

56. Brandon Flowers

57. Terrell Suggs

 

TBD