2011 Starter Grades

[AllYouNeedIsLovie 377]

A+ = Elite

A = Great

A- = Borderline great

B+ = Good

B = Borderline good

B- = Solid

C+ = Borderline solid

C = Mediocre

C- Borderline mediocre

D+ = Bad

D = Really Bad

D- = Should not have started

F = Should never be a starter

 

 

QB: Josh Freeman C-

RB: LeGarette Blount C+

WR: Mike Williams C

WR: Arrelious Benn D

TE: Kellen Winslow C

OT: Jeremy Trueblood C-

OG: Davin Joseph B+

C: Jeff Faine D+

OG: Jeremy Zuttah C-

OT: Donald Penn C+

 

DE: Adrian Clayborn B+

DT: Brian Price C (If he was healthy, grade could be higher)

DT: Gerald McCoy D (Because he was injured half the season. Was great when he played though)

DE: DaQuan Bowers C+ (Started later on in the year)

OLB: Quincy Black D-

MLB: Mason Foster C (Started off great then hit rookie wall)

OLB: Geno Hayes D

CB: Aqib Talib C

S: Sean Jones D+

S: Tanard Jackson D+

CB: Ronde Barber B-

Edited January 6, 2012 by GoodellFTL

[Packers Dynasty 2010 116]

Offense:

QB: Aaron Rodgers A+

RB: James Starks/Ryan Grant C+

FB: John Kuhn B

WR: Greg Jennings A-

WR: Jordy Nelson A-

TE: JerMichael Finley B-(If he would just shut up and concentrate on catching the ball)

LT: Marshall Newhouse C-

LG: TJ Lang C+

C: Scott Wells B+

RG: Josh Sitton B+

RT: Bryan Bulaga B+

 

Defense:

RDE: Jarius Wynn D+

NT: BJ Raji C

LDE: Ryan Pickett C

ROLB: Erik Walden D

ILB: Desmond Bishop A-

ILB: AJ Hawk B-

LOLB: Clay Matthews III B+

CB: Charles Woodson A

FS: Morgan Burnett B+

SS: Charlie Peprah C

CB: Tramon Williams B+

Edited January 6, 2012 by Packers Dynasty 2010

[.AirMcNair. 1,232]

Offense:

 

QB: Matt Hasselbeck B

RB: Chris Johnson B+

FB: Ahmard Hall C

WR1: Nate Washington B+

WR2: Damian Williams C-

LT: Michael Roos A

LG: Leroy Harris D-

C: Eugene Amano F

RG Jake Scott D

RT: David Stewart A

 

Defense:

 

DE: Derrick Morgan B-

DT: Jurrell Casey B

DT: Sen'Derrick Marks/Shaun Smith C-

DE: Jason Jones B

OLB: Akeem Ayers B

MLB: Colin McCarthy B

OLB: Will Witherspoon B+

CB: Cortland Finnegan A+

CB#2: Jason McCourty B

CB#3: Alterraun Verner B

FS: Michael Griffin C

SS: Jordan Babineaux C

 

Listed 3 CBs because both McCourty and Verner got equal playing time through the season.

 

Special Teams:

K: Rob Bironas A+

P: Brett Kern A

KR/PR Marc Mariani B

[FIDDYDEUCE 81]

Offense

QB: Joe Flacco C+

HB: Ray Rice A+

FB: Vonta Leach A+

WR1: Anquan Boldin B

WR2: Torrey Smith B

TE: Ed Dickson/Dennis Pitta A

LT: Bryant McKinnie B+

LG: Ben Grubbs A+

C: Matt Birk A

RG: Marshall Yanda A+

RT: Michael Oher B+

 

Defense

DE: Corry Redding A

NT: Terrance Cody B+

DE: Haolti Ngata A+

OLB: Terrel Suggs A+

MLB: Ray Lewis B

ILB: Jammel McClain B

OLB: Jarret Johnson A

CB1: Ladarius Webb A+

CB2: Carry Williams/Jimmy Smith B-

FS: Ed Reed B-

SS: Bernard Pollard A

 

ST

K: Billy Cundiff C

P: Sam Koch A+

KR/PR: David Reed D

 

Key Back Ups

DE/OLB: Paul Kruger B

C/G: Andre Gurode B+

DE: Pernell McPhee A+

HB: Ricky Williams B

S: Tom Zbikowski B-

[RazorStar 4,025]

QB: Tim Tebow C-

HB: Willis McGahee B+

FB: Spencer Larsen D

WR: Eric Decker D

WR: DeMaryius Thomas C-

TE: Daniel Fells C-

LT: Ryan Clady D+

LG: Zane Beadles D+

C: JD Walton F

RG: Chris Kuper C

RT: Orlando Franlkin D+

 

DE: Elvis Dumervil A-

DT: Broderick Bunkley A-

DT: Marcus Thomas C+

DE: Robert Ayers B-

SLB: Von Miller A+

MLB: Joe Mays B-

WLB: DJ Williams A-

CB: Champ Bailey A

CB: Andre Goodman D

FS: Rahim Moore D-

SS: Quinton Carter D+

 

K/KO: Matt Prater A

P: Britton Colquitt A

KR: Eddie Royal/Quan Cosby C-

Edited January 7, 2012 by RazorStar

[seanbrock 1,684]

Vick C+

McCoy A+

Schmitt C+

Jackson C

Maclin C+

Celek B

Peters A+

Mathis A+

Kelce C+

Watkins B

Herremans B

 

Cole A-

Jenkins B+

Patterson C+

Babin A-

Rolle B

Cheyney C+

Fokou C-

Samuel B

Asomugha C+

Allen C+

Coleman C+

 

Henery B+

Henry C+

Lewis D

We've had a few guys returning punts but no big plays. D-

Edited January 7, 2012 by seanbrock

[Bay 2,003]

Alex Smith B / B+

Frank Gore A-

Bruce Miller B+ - A-

 

Michael Crabtree B

Kyle Williams B

Vernon Davis B+ / A-

 

Joe Staley B+ / A-

Mike Iupati B+

Jonathan Goodwin B-

Adam Snyder B-

Anthony Davis C- / C+

 

Justin Smith A++

Issac Sopoaga B

Ray McDonald A

 

Parys Haralson B- / B - Aldon Smith A

NaVorro Bowman - A

Patrick Willis A+

Ahmad Brooks B+

 

Carlos Rogers B+

Tarell Brown B+

Dashon Goldson B+

Donte Whitner C+

 

David Akers A

Andy Lee A+

Ted Ginn A / A+

 

 

Depth:

 

Kendall Hunter B+

Chris Culliver B

Ricky Jean-Francois B-

Delanie Walker B

Alex Boone C+ / B-

Anthony Dixon C+

Ted Ginn (WR) D+/ C-

Shawntae Spencer D+ / C-

[ATL_Predator+ 1,196]

Matt Ryan B

Ovie Mughelli B+ until he got injured...

Michael Turner B-

Roddy White A+

Will Svitek B

Justin Blalock B-

Todd Mcclure B+

Joe Hawley C+

Tyson Clabo A+

Julio Jones A+

Tony Gonzalez A

 

John Abraham B

Corey Peters A-

Jonathan Babineaux A

Ray Edwards C-

Sean Weatherspoon A+

Curtis Lofton A+

Stephen Nicholas B-

Brent Grimes A

Dunta Robinson C+

William Moore B+

Thomas Decoud B

 

Matt Bryant A-

Matt Bosher B-

 

Eric Weems B-

[badgers 380]

Offense:

 

Aaron Rodgers: A+

Ryan Grant: B

John Kuhn: B+

Greg Jennings: A

Jordy Nelson: A

Jermichael Finley: B-

Chad Clifton: B

TJ Lang: B+

Scott Wells: A-

Josh Sitton: B

Bryan Bulaga: B+

 

Defense:

 

Ryan Pickett: C+

BJ Raji: C+

Whoever the fuck: D

Clay Matthews: A

Desmond Bishop: A-

AJ Hawk: C+

Erik Walden: C-

Charles Woodson: A-

Tramon Williams: B-

Charlie Peprah: C

Morgan Burnett: B-

 

Special Teams:

 

Mason Crosby: A-

Tim Masthay: B+

Randall Cobb: A-

 

Depth:

 

All the guys who have gotten / may get significant playing time for injured starters but aren't our starters going into the playoffs.

 

Donald Driver: B+

Randall Cobb: B+

James Jones: B

Marshall Newhouse: C-

James Starks: B-

DJ Smith: B

Mike Neal: C-

Jarius Wynn: C

Howard Green: C+

CJ Wilson: C+

Brad Jones: B-

Frank Zombo: C

[SteVo+ 3,702]

 

QB Michael Vick: C+

RB LeSean McCoy: A+

WR DeSean Jackson B-

WR Jeremy Maclin B-

TE Brent Celek B

LT Jason Peters A+

LG Evan Mathis B+

C Jason Kelce B

RG Danny Watkins B

RT Todd Herremans B+

 

DE Jason Babin A

DT Cullen Jenkins B+

DT Derek Landri A-

DE Trent Cole A

SLB Casey Matthews D

MLB Jamar Chaney D+

WLB Brian Rolle C+

CB Asante Samuel A

CB Nnamdi Asomugha B+

S Nate Allen B

S Kurt Coleman D+

 

K Alex Henery B+

P Chas Henry B

[BwareDWare94 723]

Offense:

Tony Romo A

Demarco Murray B+/Felix Jones C

Tony Fiametta A

Miles Austin B-

Dez Bryant B+/Laurent Robinson A- (in his limited time)

Jason Witten B+

Tyron Smith B+

Kyle Kosier C

Phil Costa F

Montrae Holland B/Derrick Dockery C

Doug Free C

 

Defense:

Kenyon Coleman B

Jay Ratliff B+

Jason Hatcher B

DeMarcus Ware A+

Bradie James B-

Sean Lee B+

Anthony Spencer B+

Terence Newman C-

Mike Jenkins C+/Orlando Scandrick B-

Gerald Sensabaugh B

Abram Elam C

 

ST

Dan Bailey B-

Mat McBriar B

[FartWaffles 1,857]

QB: T.J. Yates B-

RB: Arian Foster A+

FB: Lawrence Vickers B

WR: Andre Johnson A-

WR: Kevin Walter C

TE: Owen Daniels B

 

LT: Duane Brown A+

LG: Wade Smith B-

C: Chris Myers A+

RG: Mike Brisiel B+

RT: Eric Winston B-

 

DE: J.J. Watt B+

NT: Shaun Cody B

DE: Antonio Smith A-

 

OLB: Connor Barwin A

ILB: Brian Cushing A+

ILB: DeMeco Ryans B-

OLB: Brooks Reed B

 

CB: Johnathan Joseph A+

CB: Kareem Jackson C+

FS: Danieal Manning A-

SS: Glover Quin B-

 

----------------------------------

 

QB: Matt Schaub A

RB: Ben Tate B+

FB: James Casey B-

WR: Jacoby Jones C

TE: Joel Dreessen B

OLB: Mario Williams A-

CB: Jason Allen B-